2″ Robey No4 light live steam traction engine

Advert

2″ Robey No4 light live steam traction engine

Home Forums General Questions 2″ Robey No4 light live steam traction engine

Viewing 25 posts - 26 through 50 (of 52 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #615518
    derek blake
    Participant
      @derekblake72550

      Hi All

      Has anyone had dealings with Steamways engineering and John Clarke, he’s advised me he can do my boiler but after the awful experience I had with the last boiler maker I thought it best to check the service.

      any thought gratefully received as the cost is every penny I have.

      Advert
      #615521
      JasonB
      Moderator
        @jasonb

        Looks like the same address Lynx use, you may want to do a search for posts related to them

        #615522
        derek blake
        Participant
          @derekblake72550

          Thanks Jason, I actually did and was hoping it wasn’t the same person.

          looks like it is, I never have any luck with boilers..

          #616018
          derek blake
          Participant
            @derekblake72550

            Hi all

            Could I please ask if anyone has pictures of how the cylinder fixing holes are drilled in new traction engine boilers.

            on the Allchin I made a little jig with the same curvature as the boiler barrel , I see some setup in a mill but I would still like to understand how you work out the angles.

            would the easiest way be to make a jig that can rotate the boiler so the fixing hole is facing directly upwards as you work your way around.

            this isn’t something I need to do for a very long time but I’d still like to understand the correct procedure.

            kind regards

            Del

            made

            #616022
            Anonymous

              When i drilled the holes for fixing the smokebox to the boiler I drilled the holes in the smokebox using the rotary table. I then picked up on each hole with a magdrill and drilled through. Of course I have steel boilers. They weigh close on 100kg so are way to big and heavy for me to manhandle onto the vertical mill.

              drilling_smokebox_me.jpg

              When I get around to the cylinder mounting i will drill the holes in the cylinder flange on the vertical mill using an angle plate to set the angle for each hole. The holes will be oversize to allow for the cylinder being pulled down onto the gasket. Once I am happy with the cylinder position I'll make a silver steel punch and spot punch through each hole. Then I'll pick up on each location with a pointer in the magdrill chuck. Exact positioning isn't critical. Clearances need to be quite large to ensure the cylinder sits down properly rather than binding on the studs.

              Andrew

              #616030
              JasonB
              Moderator
                @jasonb

                I clamped the cylinder to the boiler and just made a sleeve that slipped into one of the holes in the cylinder flange that was drilled to the tapping size and used that to guide the drill bit in the cordless and a simple card template to help ensure the drill was perpendicular to the surface.

                After each was drilled it was tapped and a temporary screw fitted before moving on to the next

                #616031
                derek blake
                Participant
                  @derekblake72550

                  Thank you both, that’s really helpful.

                  Del

                  #618664
                  derek blake
                  Participant
                    @derekblake72550

                    Good evening

                    I’ve just started forming my tender sides, could I please ask some advice regarding the corners, so I cut material out to give room for the excess or continue to hammer flat?

                    thank you in advance.

                    79f0b1d1-1667-4292-ae37-e948261d8101.jpeg

                    #618676
                    Anonymous

                      It's not clear what the material is, but once the material has kinked it will be very difficult to get the kinks out by hammering alone. It might just be possible by heating to red hot and using a wooden mallet.

                      I haven't flanged my tender sides yet. The former is made and the blanks machined. I will be forming red hot and the job is made easier as my tender sides have a large radius on the flange.

                      When I made the spectacle plates for my engines I formed them red hot over a steel former. The plates were made from 3mm cold rolled steel sheet and have fairly sharp internal corners:

                      spectacle plate rear.jpg

                      This is the former:

                      former - modified.jpg

                      And the partial former, a test piece and home made wooden mallet:

                      hot forming test  kit.jpg

                      To summarise; the tender sides really need to be formed hot, and avoid kinks at all costs. For convex curves, as shown, the metal has to compress, or increase in depth, as it is folded over. Trying to bend cold makes that very difficult indeed. On the test piece note that the depth of metal on the curve is larger than the straight flanges although the blank started uniformly oversize.

                      Andrew

                      #618678
                      derek blake
                      Participant
                        @derekblake72550

                        Many thanks Andrew, hopefully I have been over keen and ruined anything.

                        I did heat it but feel I wasn’t giving it enough, so I have heated the brass to a cherry red for another hammer tomorrow.

                        I do feel the kinks won’t go, so I may need to put my thinking cap on.

                        many thanks

                        Del

                        #618681
                        Anonymous

                          Just to be clear I formed my plates while the metal was red hot. Presumably by heating the brass this evening and hammering tomorrow the heating was only intended to anneal the brass?

                          Personally I'd use steel for the tender sides. Much cheaper and better behaved when forming. This is an oiler tray made from 1mm cold rolled sheet formed hot on the same former as the spectacle plate for convenience:

                          oiler_tray_trial.jpg

                          Andrew

                          #618684
                          derek blake
                          Participant
                            @derekblake72550

                            Hi Andrew

                            Yes just to anneal, the kinks came out with a gentle pull from some flat pliers so hopefully I can anneal again and be more precise with the hammer blows.

                            I just wasn’t sure if you were actually supposed to make cuts or remove excess before or while you are doing the corners.

                            Del

                            #618688
                            Anonymous
                              Posted by derek blake on 26/10/2022 22:31:37:

                              …make cuts or remove excess before or while you are doing the corners.

                              Some people do cut out Vs before bending to remove excess material. But probably more common when using steel as the sections can be easily welded together afterwards.

                              Andrew

                              #618689
                              derek blake
                              Participant
                                @derekblake72550

                                Thank you Andrew, I just found a build thread on TT and it shows exactly what I’m doing, the builder is using the same brass and former plus he has kinks in the corners and he’s managed to flatten.

                                So I will take your advice and be more gentle not to kink the material so much.

                                fingers crossed 🤞

                                #618697
                                Paul Kemp
                                Participant
                                  @paulkemp46892

                                  Derek,

                                  Its about 45 years since I annealed brass for forming so memory is a bit sketchy but I am pretty sure you don’t want to heat it to red heat to anneal (due to the zinc). I have a vague memory of swiping the surface with soap and heating till the soap goes brown / black and letting it cool naturally to anneal. Brass if I remember right tends to work harden quickly (much quicker than plain copper) so regular annealing as soon as it starts to resist is the name of the game. The “extra” material needs to flow somewhere and if the metal has hardened that won’t happen easily or well.

                                  Paul.

                                  #618711
                                  JasonB
                                  Moderator
                                    @jasonb

                                    I took the option of cutting a piece out and silver soldering in a separate part, the Fowler does have quite a large radius bend though rather than the tighter one you and Andrew show.

                                    #618713
                                    derek blake
                                    Participant
                                      @derekblake72550

                                      Thanks very much guys. I will give it another go this evening and see how I get on.

                                      I will frequently heat, but if I still won’t go I will probably considering removing material as Jason mentioned.

                                      Del

                                      #618715
                                      derek blake
                                      Participant
                                        @derekblake72550

                                        I found this picture on TT which looks like what I’m trying to achieve, so fingers crossed I can somewhat replicate.

                                        3a1cb39d-77b5-4e42-88c6-155b05e96c80.jpeg

                                        #618802
                                        derek blake
                                        Participant
                                          @derekblake72550

                                          So sides formed, could be better but I’ve never done it before. One side has a bow but I am hoping the brass angle will pull this flat once riveted in.

                                          I tried to flatten the panel with no success.

                                          9a96b63f-1d69-4ee7-ae36-d96d95e7ab94.jpeg

                                          04678ee7-87ee-44e1-aec4-b250f150178b.jpeg

                                          #620674
                                          derek blake
                                          Participant
                                            @derekblake72550

                                            Good evening

                                            Could I please ask some advice regarding the pipe sizes on the 3 inch burrell as drawings are not clear, is it 1/4 pipe from pump to bunker tank?

                                            I gave unions on the pump for 1/4 pipe but will have to get different ones if it actually supposed to be 3/16 pipe.

                                            Many thanks in advance.

                                            Del

                                            #620676
                                            Harry Wilkes
                                            Participant
                                              @harrywilkes58467

                                              I have a 3" Burrell and the pipework is 1/4 copper yes

                                              H

                                              #620677
                                              derek blake
                                              Participant
                                                @derekblake72550

                                                Many thanks Harry, every bit of pipe on the engine?

                                                Thanks Del

                                                #620683
                                                derek blake
                                                Participant
                                                  @derekblake72550

                                                  I was thinking about the ones into the boiler clacks as well, from what I can see on other peoples engines they look smaller than 1/4 inch.

                                                  Del

                                                  #620960
                                                  derek blake
                                                  Participant
                                                    @derekblake72550

                                                    Good evening

                                                    Ive piped up the pump today with 1/4 inch pipe, I’m about to look at the pipes for valves on the steam head the one towards the water lifter and the other to the injector.

                                                    Could a kind sole confirm if these should be 3/16 pipe?

                                                    kind regards

                                                    Del

                                                    #622842
                                                    derek blake
                                                    Participant
                                                      @derekblake72550

                                                      Good afternoon

                                                      could I please ask a question regarding the 3 inch burrell water pump, it would great but my question is when the bypass valve is open should water still pump out of the main pipe that feeds the boiler, or should this stop?

                                                      im assuming unless it’s under steam pressure it would still pump out? Just trying to understand if everything is fine or if something needs work.

                                                      kind regards

                                                    Viewing 25 posts - 26 through 50 (of 52 total)
                                                    • Please log in to reply to this topic. Registering is free and easy using the links on the menu at the top of this page.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Latest Replies

                                                    Home Forums General Questions Topics

                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
                                                    Viewing 25 topics - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

                                                    View full reply list.

                                                    Advert

                                                    Newsletter Sign-up