|terry callaghan||23/09/2013 22:34:37|
|237 forum posts|
Hi chaps.can anyone who owns a tom senior please let me if the arbour should have a keyway in it.i cant work out what holds the cutting wheel in place.my arbour does not have a keyway, and I was told that pressure on the side of the cutter face keeps it in place.this cant be right can it . Michael
|ronan walsh||24/09/2013 00:59:36|
|546 forum posts|
I have a tom senior, and two different size horizontal arbours for it , 3/4" and 1". Both have keyways running along their entire lengths, 1/4" off the top of my head. No way would the pressure of the nut hold a horizontal milling cutter in place while cutting , even with light cuts.
Edited By ronan walsh on 24/09/2013 01:00:39
|Alan Jackson||24/09/2013 10:06:29|
260 forum posts
Hi Terry, Ronan,
Not wishing to contradict but my Tom Senior M1 has a 1" horizontal arbour without a keyway and I have no trouble clamping horizontal milling cutters sufficiently just using the nut, which, does not have to be more than just nipped up to drive the cutter. Admittedly I mostly use fairly thin section cutters i.e. slitting saws etc and this has the advantage of letting the slitting saw slip (tongue twister) rather than breaking the saw blade.
|RICHARD GREEN 2||24/09/2013 11:57:18|
|327 forum posts|
I fully agree, I've used large horizontal mills for years without using the keyway, used large cutters with no problem at all, the keyway would possibly be an advantage in some cases but not 100% necessary, however, I would use the keyway for very heavy cuts.
I've got 2 Tom senior M1's , I've used the horizontal arbor a few times but have never needed to use the keyway.
|Stub Mandrel||24/09/2013 13:22:39|
4315 forum posts
Surely, sawing stainless steel stock several slightly slack slitting saws should sometimes slip safely, substantially saving some shattered saws - circumstances suggest skimming surface slows slicing.
|colin hawes||24/09/2013 13:30:31|
|560 forum posts|
I spent many years on toolroom machines of all sorts.With this sort of work a key is unnecessary and model making is similar. Only on production work where a mill is driven to it's limits of strain is a key essential. Under those conditions the hardened arbour nut can explode with the winding up strain, especially with a gang of large cutters, if no key is fitted. We used to have a guard over the arbor nut anyway. Colin
|Alan Jackson||24/09/2013 20:19:57|
260 forum posts
Now that is as fine an example of alliteration as you will ever get in the model world. Surely superflous to suggest otherwise,Top marks Stub
6390 forum posts
Unfortunately this seems to be common practice in industry which is why my arbors have a massive amount of scoring.
|colin hawes||25/09/2013 10:20:03|
|560 forum posts|
What Bazyle says is quite right and some cutters are not chamfered at the ends of their bore which exacerbates the problem if they slip; however many horizontal mill arbours don't have a keyway.The main problem here is that if the cutter does slip due to excessive overload it can tighten the nut and make it very difficutt to undo,largely because some arbours that are driven by taper friction have no spanner flats at the taper end to grip it tightly enough to make good use of a long spanner at the nut end.
If you have a keyway some of the spacers need a keyway too to enable their use on thin cutters. Colin
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.