By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Forum House Ad Zone

Universal Grinding machine construction series?

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
Diane Carney11/09/2013 14:21:58
Moderator
414 forum posts
11 photos

I am posting this as a bit of an experiment. I would like to try to gauge the reaction to a proposed construction series. I am mindful that only a very small percentage of the readership partakes in this forum and also that if the reaction here is completely negative and I decide to run it anyway I will never hear the end of it.

Anyway... here goes:
I have been offered a long article - a full construction series with very many drawings - for a universal grinding machine. The machine is part manual and part CNC and is manufactured from stock material - no castings. The table is 23 inches x 5 inches and the between centres grinding capacity is 12 inches long x 5 inches dia. When complete it will be a surface grinder, a cylindrical grinder and an internal grinder also.

The writer is known to us and his work is thorough and clear.
This is something a little out of the ordinary for Model Enginer and I think it has great value. What are your thoughts?

Diane

Tomfilery11/09/2013 14:29:27
136 forum posts
4 photos

Diane,

Surely you mean for MEW (rather than ME) - otherwise what is the point in having the two titles?

Regards Tom

KWIL11/09/2013 14:34:29
3549 forum posts
70 photos

Go for it Diana. We will not doubt learn a few tricks.

OuBallie11/09/2013 14:52:13
avatar
1164 forum posts
662 photos

Diane,

I'd be interested, as I am in need of one.

Geoff - Three classic cars need restoring.

Simon036211/09/2013 15:05:02
219 forum posts
77 photos

Diane,

I would be very interested to read this. Not sure that I would ever build it in its entirety but the designs and processes would definitely be of interest. As an aside, could you contemplate having the entire series of articles (assuming you do publish) collated together so that it is possible to read without hunting for sections, or losing the flow of the design?

Simon

Andrew Johnston11/09/2013 15:37:57
avatar
6575 forum posts
701 photos

At first glance it wouldn't seem that I'd be interested, as I already have a surface grinder and cylindrical grinder with external and internal capability. However, I would be keen to read the series, especially if it dealt with the design calculations and trade offs needed to get the necessary sub-micron accuracy., rather than just a blow by blow account of making the parts.

What would also be very valuable is a practical discussion of how to use surface and cylindrical grinders, such as wheel selection versus material and finish, coolant or no coolant, feedrates, step overs, sparkout strategies and the like.

Regards,

Andrew

Ian P11/09/2013 16:06:34
avatar
2578 forum posts
114 photos

Put me down as another positive vote.

I'm not saying I would build the whole thing but apart from reading what sounds like an interesting article I would probably learn something about how grinding machines work in practice.

As regards ME/MEW (as Tom brought it up) I'm not fussed but the thought of having 'tools' making articles mixed in with ME appeals to me so if its a voting matter, stick to your guns Diane!

Ian P

Steamer191511/09/2013 16:12:14
avatar
168 forum posts
42 photos

I would welcome such a series - especially in ME.

Steve.

Michael Gilligan11/09/2013 16:23:55
avatar
20091 forum posts
1042 photos
Posted by Tomfilery on 11/09/2013 14:29:27:

Diane,

Surely you mean for MEW (rather than ME) - otherwise what is the point in having the two titles?

Regards Tom

.

As Tom so rightly says ... This should be in Model Engineers Workshop !!

[assuming that title continues to exist]

MEW has come-in for criticism recently, because [with the notable exeption of the StepperHead series] it does not run articles of this calibre.

I regret to say this is probably "the final straw" for my subscription to MEW.

MichaelG.

 

 

 

 

Edited By Michael Gilligan on 11/09/2013 16:24:31

Neil Greenaway11/09/2013 16:28:52
71 forum posts
3 photos

Hi All,

I would be interested to read this article however only subscribe to MEW - if you look at the title of MEW I would have thought it would be better suited to a workshop magazine. I do find it difficult recently to see what direction MEW is heading in for the future? My interests are more around workshop machinery but still enjoyed learning about other machines (clocks, steam, stirling etc) as it was another wing of my engineering career and hobby so to speak!

Neil

michael cole11/09/2013 16:31:40
165 forum posts

Posted by Andrew Johnston on 11/09/2013 15:37:57:

What would also be very valuable is a practical discussion of how to use surface and cylindrical grinders, such as wheel selection versus material and finish, coolant or no coolant, feedrates, step overs, sparkout strategies and the like.

I would much like such a article. Mostly I would like second Andrew comment as above.

It is one thing to read up on lathe work and then have a go yourself, This is I think most of us start out, but I would not think of doing this with a grinder unless I had some very detailed instrections first.

Mike

JasonB11/09/2013 16:34:44
avatar
Moderator
22585 forum posts
2638 photos
1 articles

Another vote to stick it in MEW.

Whatever way you go if there are lots of drawings make sure they are reasonably correct

J

Gray6211/09/2013 16:38:12
1057 forum posts
16 photos

Yep, it gets my vote whichever magazine runs it, should prove interesting

CB

DerryUK11/09/2013 16:38:55
125 forum posts

Diane is Editor of ME and doing her best for her magazine. Bravo!

Should still be in MEW though.

Stephen Benson11/09/2013 16:43:01
avatar
203 forum posts
69 photos

Sounds like another nail in the MEW coffin

Andrew Johnston11/09/2013 16:56:53
avatar
6575 forum posts
701 photos
Posted by CoalBurner on 11/09/2013 16:38:12:

Yep, it gets my vote whichever magazine runs it

Half in one, half in the other? devil

Andrew

Michael Gilligan11/09/2013 17:04:22
avatar
20091 forum posts
1042 photos

Andrew a.k.a Solomon

MichaelG.

Harold Hall 111/09/2013 17:11:21
418 forum posts
4 photos

Could you Diane give a very approximate estimate as to how long, long is.

Also, I would have thought that you must have a limit to how many non modelling pages you can justify in the magazine, but maybe not. However, if so, then would it not limit the number of non modelling pages which could be devoted to the smaller workshop articles which would surely suit a larger number of your readers.

Harold

Russell Eberhardt11/09/2013 17:14:18
avatar
2728 forum posts
86 photos

It sounds interesting even if I won't be building it. Another vote for putting it in MEW.

Russell.

Tony Pratt 111/09/2013 17:16:09
1930 forum posts
12 photos

Gets my vote, but MEW is the place for it.

Tony

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
Eccentric July 5 2018
Eccentric Engineering
Dreweatts
Rapid RC
cowells
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest