By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Allendale Jan 24th

MEW200

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
DerryUK09/02/2013 11:28:30
125 forum posts

I like the motoring section.

Makes a change from all that CAD/CAM/CNC stuff.

John Stevenson09/02/2013 14:18:03
avatar
Moderator
5068 forum posts
3 photos

Can't put my finger on it but to say this was a 200th edition special it somehow seemed lacking in content ?

Or is it just me ?

John Shepherd09/02/2013 14:42:43
216 forum posts
7 photos

Certainly nothing special if it is supposed to be a celebratory edition.

_Paul_09/02/2013 15:16:16
avatar
543 forum posts
31 photos

Bit of an anticlimax...

ASF09/02/2013 16:53:18
130 forum posts
12 photos

Bit of a shame really.

Not much in there that cant be found online. It was nice to see complete articles from start to finish though.

Many articles seem to be drawn out of late that could have been completed in one issue. Throw a few more pages in and complete articles in an issue please

Michael Gilligan09/02/2013 17:05:08
avatar
14954 forum posts
638 photos
Posted by DerryUK on 09/02/2013 11:28:30:

I like the motoring section.

Makes a change from all that CAD/CAM/CNC stuff.

 

 

"Other Motoring Magazines are available"

Edited By Michael Gilligan on 09/02/2013 17:06:45

martin perman09/02/2013 18:31:11
avatar
1778 forum posts
75 photos

Gentlemen,

I'm going to buck the trend and say that I think its a very good colection of articles, I quite like the motoring piece firstly because I own a classic car and secondly because as a Newsletter writer of a club I belong to I find that putting an outsider into the pages of the general club subjects lightens it up and gives the reader something else to think about.

The various engineering subjects are interesting as well particularly as I've never seen them, the ball turning piece iis of particular interest to me, as the saying goes you can please some of the people some of the time and not most of the time smiley

Martin P

David Littlewood09/02/2013 19:24:25
533 forum posts

Martin,

I agree the ball turning article was particularly interesting, but it was also the most frustrating, in that there was insufficient explanation or constructional detail. The function of some of the parts was quite difficult to fathom, at least I found them so.

David

martin perman09/02/2013 19:33:48
avatar
1778 forum posts
75 photos

Isnt that part of the challenge, to make it I will have to adapt it to suit my lathe so a lot of the detail will be off no use to me but the basic premise is good enough for me to copy.

Martin P

Stub Mandrel09/02/2013 20:57:06
avatar
4307 forum posts
291 photos
1 articles

I found it a good issue, especially nice to have a complete Harold Hall article in it. George Thomas can claim 'prior art' on that, but it is different in all the details.

The one I found hardest to follow was the 'folding machine'. Is it a folder or rolls? I must spend more time on it.

One of thsese days I will make a VERY SIMPLE ball turning attachment - they seem to attract complication like a magnet. You just need a pillar that can be attached to the cross-slide with a rotating tool holder witha long handle and a way to adjust the toolbit in small increments (e.g. a 40 tpi 1mm pitch screw pressing against it).

I haven't read the car article yet but it fits the ethos of MEW.

Neil

Ray Lyons10/02/2013 07:10:02
160 forum posts
1 photos

Surely the car item is in the wrong magazine. There are any number of publications on the newsagents shelves covering such subjects. I only see 6 precious pages of my model engineering magazine lost to something which is better covered elsewhere.

IanT10/02/2013 10:37:13
1433 forum posts
141 photos

To be honest - I received my copy yesterday and I thought it was just a little mundane for a 200th (and presumably therefore special) Edition.

I also really wish that they would not place advertisments (7 pages of them) inside the main body of the magazine section. I like to book-bind my copies and don't really want to include this material too.

So no cigars from me I'm afraid.

IanT

Russell Eberhardt10/02/2013 11:05:45
avatar
2564 forum posts
85 photos

Didn't realise it was the 200 th edition untill I saw this thread. Pity, if a bit more of a splash had been made it could have gained publicity.

Russell.

Michael Gilligan10/02/2013 11:46:02
avatar
14954 forum posts
638 photos

Russell,

David did make an effort to publicise it

See preview thread, here

MichaelG.

Alan Hopwood10/02/2013 12:23:04
avatar
32 forum posts

I was most surprised by the fact that Harold Hall did not even bother to tip his hat in the direction of old GHT. Many of the ideas of the small rotary table would look to be a direct lift from George's design, and may I say that I find GHT more easy to follow in his instructions.

Alan.

Michael Gilligan10/02/2013 12:29:56
avatar
14954 forum posts
638 photos

Alan,

Harold Hall did comment, on the preview thread mentioned above.

01/02/2013 08:57:56

MichaelG.

Harold Hall 110/02/2013 15:04:55
418 forum posts
4 photos

I am sorry Alan that you find it surprising I did not give GTH a mention but I am not well read, do not have the time, and did not know of his table.

I cannot say that my offering is totally from my own head but prompted by a photograph I had seen during my time as editor, I now find is was acctually in issue 1 of MEW. And the person who made that was a Tony Daish and I did not give him a mention either.

It is probable that GHT had also been influenced by others offerings.

I have now found the GHT table in the Hemmingway catalogue and can see some long distance similarities. Though I do not see fine adjustments of the stops, 24 hole indexing and, for me, the inbuilt facility to be able to centre workpieces very easy.

It is quite probable that over the years I have produced items that had a noticeable similarity with items designed by others, its inevitable. I can assure you that this is quite coincidental. For me, designing an item is much more satisfying than the making. If I just largely copied others designs most of the satisfaction would be lost.

If eventually Alan you decided to make one please feel free to make contact with me via my web site should you have any questions regarding the areas that you do not find clear. I will do my best to help.

Harold

John Stevenson10/02/2013 15:19:34
avatar
Moderator
5068 forum posts
3 photos

GHT was influenced a lot by Jack Radford.

Radford was very innovative, GHT was more concerned with detail. It always amuses me that GHT found that he needed to travel to NZ to see Radford but Radford never saw the need to visit GHT.

Russell Eberhardt10/02/2013 15:57:32
avatar
2564 forum posts
85 photos

If the magazine is short of good articles it would be nice to see some of J.A.Radford's articles reprinted.

Russell.

Michael Gilligan10/02/2013 15:59:54
avatar
14954 forum posts
638 photos
Posted by Russell Eberhardt on 10/02/2013 15:57:32:

If the magazine is short of good articles it would be nice to see some of J.A.Radford's articles reprinted.

Russell.

.

Seconded !!

MichaelG.

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
emcomachinetools
Allendale Electronics
Warco
ChesterUK
Ausee.com.au
cowells
Eccentric July 5 2018
Eccentric Engineering
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest