By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Forum House Ad Zone

Steel tyres on alloy rims

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
Jon Lawes25/01/2022 11:51:51
avatar
872 forum posts

I've just finished making the mild steel tyres which on the 2" Burrell I'm building will be riveted to the aluminium front wheel rims using iron rivets. This seems like a lot of dissimilar metals so I thought about using something like Upol etch primer on both surfaces before bringing them together.

Is this overkill or am I worrying about nothing? Is there a better product you can recommend?

Thanks,

Jon.

old mart25/01/2022 12:04:57
3717 forum posts
233 photos

When assembling aircraft parts, a compound was always used to seal the joints between housings and bushes, for instance. You could assemble your wheels using a coating of wet primer paint which will stop the ingress of water and damp. After assembly, just wipe off the excess with a solvent damped rag.

Jon Lawes25/01/2022 12:17:33
avatar
872 forum posts
Posted by old mart on 25/01/2022 12:04:57:

When assembling aircraft parts, a compound was always used to seal the joints between housings and bushes, for instance. You could assemble your wheels using a coating of wet primer paint which will stop the ingress of water and damp. After assembly, just wipe off the excess with a solvent damped rag.

Ah I remember it, I can't remember what it was officially called but I think we called it "goat sh*t".

Thanks, thats a good idea.

old mart25/01/2022 12:28:17
3717 forum posts
233 photos

Wet primer was just one of the specifications, we also used JC5A, Mastinox and certain PRC products which would be difficult and expensive to get hold of.

JasonB25/01/2022 12:58:06
avatar
Moderator
22557 forum posts
2634 photos
1 articles

Not noticed any problems on my MJ Fowler after 10 years with the tyres or rear strakes, neither the spokes which are done with copper rivits. Same goes for the Minnie after 25yrs all bare metal contact but I don't expect either to be air worthy.

Dave Smith 1425/01/2022 13:39:17
212 forum posts
43 photos

Duralac is the yellow conformal coating used to protect interfaying surfaces in a lot of Aerospace applications. The permanent joints on my tender and loco chassis are using it.

old mart25/01/2022 13:41:39
3717 forum posts
233 photos

I wouldn't expect a precision model to be kept outdoors or in damp conditions, but it is easy to seal the joints when assembling and removes a littly worry.

Jon Lawes25/01/2022 13:44:13
avatar
872 forum posts

Thank you, I suspect I will be able to find a source. Duralac does ring a bell.

vic francis28/01/2022 08:04:49
77 forum posts
7 photos

Fine advice from old mart! Precision models left outside , well I have seen a few suffer this sad fate; the damp shed... perhaps due to various unfortunate circumstances.I have a couple as well; it is the metalwork which needs thought, I wondered about plating , or lacquer coat. I have a gm showmans which had this fate of the damp shed... took alot to get it reasonable, but the metalwork has some staining / pitting ... anyway a coat of lacquer, but what type ? Seen it flake badly in time. What do you chaps think?

keep the good work going Jon!

regards

vic

Former Member28/01/2022 09:02:10
1085 forum posts

[This posting has been removed]

Bob Worsley28/01/2022 09:44:07
116 forum posts

I would have thought that using iron rivets into aluminium rims is the problem due to impact damage? Need a softer metal, copper or aluminium?

Bare copper and aluminium together isn't a good idea, just look at copper tags on aluminium chassis with a bit of damp, total disintegration, why tags are always tinned.

JasonB28/01/2022 10:05:16
avatar
Moderator
22557 forum posts
2634 photos
1 articles

For tyres and strakes the contrast of a copper rivit will show so steel/iron are usually used for those but a shallow 60deg CSK is best to avoid excess force to fill the CSK.

On the strakes which will be painted and need a full snap head forming then copper is the usual choice to avoid swelling the leg of the tee rings and what is suggested in the build articles for the Burrell, Minnie and Fowler A7 all of which have cast aluminium rims

As I said earlier my Minnie is not showing any problems after 25yrs of bare steel on aluminium with copper rivits

Dave Halford28/01/2022 11:07:22
2001 forum posts
23 photos

Oddly back in the day I had an Aussie Ford Falcon Fairmont. It had composite wheels with alloy centres and steel rims without any issues, whereas Landrovers alloy door panels on steel frames would corrode where they touched.

Nigel McBurney 128/01/2022 11:56:21
avatar
999 forum posts
3 photos

I would not worry about disimilar metals and corrosion you will possibly have more problems getting the rivet heads to look correct,use softer copper rivets which also may also require annealing, I cracked the cast alloy front rim on an Allchin trying to get decent rivets for the spokes,in the end turned the front rims from solid steel blanks,

Bob Unitt 128/01/2022 12:33:09
avatar
202 forum posts
33 photos

I had a similar problem with a model cannon I made to live on the mantelpiece, people tend to pick it up to look at it and the steel components suffered badly from corrosion by sweaty fingers. I painted it over 10 years ago with Rustins Metal Lacquer, since when there's been no corrosion whatsoever.

Tim Stevens28/01/2022 18:23:57
avatar
1584 forum posts

The problem you are likely to face is 'electrolytic corrosion'. This involves two different metals in contact, and damp or wet conditions. This creates a feeble, but continuous, electric cell - and the more reactive* metal is corroded most. With iron and aluminium, the iron will rust a bit but the Aluminium will corrode to a white jelly of aluminium oxide. Separating the two metals will only help if there is NO contact - iron rivets in aluminium and you've no chance. Unless you live is Death Valley etc. Or you could completely cover the rivetted area with a permanent layer of insulator bonded on all over. Not easy.

If you use rivets of aluminium (ideally the same recipe as the rim) then you have a better chance, but the, steel spokes will then become the problem. Aluminium spokes will then help, and lift the area away from the main source of damp.

* yes, normally we think of aluminium pans etc as not reactive. This is because of a surface layer of impervious oxide which prevents the metal showing. Electricity will cut through this layer, and the corrosion starts in earnest.

And copper rivets, or brass, will be worse than steel ones - sorry!

Cheers, Tim

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Support Our Partners
Rapid RC
Dreweatts
Eccentric Engineering
Eccentric July 5 2018
cowells
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest