|250 forum posts|
Hi - In a nearby housing development I have noticed the builder is using Fairy Liquid in the concrete mix used for the footings of a new house. Does this have the approval of the building inspectoater and why would you want to do this anyway? I am sure someone will have the answer.
1214 forum posts
The addition of Fairy liquid in mortar used in bricklaying aids the workability of the mortar, haven’t heard of it being added to concrete mixes though, I think that it is frowned upon by authorities because apparently degrades the final strength of the mortar, apparently affects the chemical process. Dave W
|Robert Atkinson 2||24/05/2021 18:24:02|
1091 forum posts
It used to be common practice. Washing up liquid is cheaper than "proper" plasticiser.
The main ingreadient in washing liquid is sodium laureth sulphate the same thing
|duncan webster||24/05/2021 18:24:37|
|3526 forum posts|
There are approved plasticisers for mortar/concrete, and I'll bet they are not a lot more expensive. According to wikepedia correct use actually makes concrete stronger as it reduces the amount of water needed to make the concrete flow, and excess water makes concrete weaker
|697 forum posts|
My son is a builder -- says not required in concrete - waste of time
Some builders due use Fairy, probably do to them being too tight to buy FEBMIX which is the recommend additive , and as David Dickinson would say, cheap as chips,
Edited By br on 24/05/2021 18:27:14
|Gordon Smith 1||24/05/2021 18:27:10|
|45 forum posts|
Back in the 1960's we used Daz.
|697 forum posts|
We had a builder near us, best described as a happy chappy, he always used OMO
Artthur C Clarke is the clue.
21467 forum posts
Not unknown for the fairy bottle to be filled with proper plasticiser as it's easy to squirt a bit into the mixer if mixing on site.
Although not really needed for domestic footings plasticized concrete is available from most good ready mixed companies and has it's uses.
Best bet is to buy something like Mastercrete which has the additives already in the cement for when mixing mortar or render then you get the right proportions
|578 forum posts|
Could you tell me where to buy Fairy Liquid for less then £3.00 for 5 litres please.
|Bill Dawes||24/05/2021 19:10:23|
|476 forum posts|
Not a concrete technologist but I would have thought the danger is weakening the concrete with too liberal usage causing foaming.
|Rob Wheatley||24/05/2021 19:16:00|
|35 forum posts|
Bet the mixer is sparkling clean and the builders have very soft hands though.
|old mart||24/05/2021 20:00:29|
|3349 forum posts|
I have used it with cement on a syringe made for injecting it. Without a small ammount of plasticiser, it would be impossible to use. PVA adhesives are also useful in the cement mix, it enhances the adherance to older concrete.
|not done it yet||24/05/2021 20:20:24|
|6350 forum posts|
Enough to form bubbles will very much increase the workability of the mix. Not good for the strength as concrete relies on good compaction for maximum strength development.
Masonry cement, for brick-laying, etc incorporated an air entraining additive to improve the workability and use of mortars where ultimate strength is not required (mortar should be weaker than the bricks/blocks). It is far better to replace brickwork pointing, if building movement causes cracks, than replacing bricks🙂 .
Far better to use the correct additives, approved for the job, than washing-up liquid.
I once had to visit a concrete user who had found low strength concrete (cube testing) results which had been used in concrete pilings. The bulk cement had been delivered by a tanker previously used for washing powder product/ingredient. The concrete pilings actually smelt of ammonia (which presumably retarded the setting of the concrete). I don’t know if later strength tests were accepted or if the pilings had to be replaced. An expensive exercise.
The concrete supplier knew the cause before I arrived - he already had cement samples and cube test results - and I knew of the outside contractor that delivered the dodgy load to the depot - before it was transferred to a company tanker prior to final delivery to the ready-mixed concrete site cement silo. Those pilings might still be propping up something in Linford (now part of Milton Keynes).
Edited By not done it yet on 24/05/2021 20:23:03
|522 forum posts|
I have run several 4and 2 gangs of bricklayers and fairy is not used in concrete but is better than febmix in mortar and if you lay bricks with our local sand you would be pleased to add a dash of fairy .Used it for all of my fifty years in the building trade and of all of the washing up liquids fairy is the cheapest and best in the long run as you only use a squirt,and after all this time 10years since I retired I havn't seen any deteriation in the buildings I worked on.
|john carruthers||26/05/2021 09:16:03|
611 forum posts
As a plasterer's mate I used a few drops in a mixer load as a deflocculant to prevent the mix balling.
|Grindstone Cowboy||26/05/2021 10:51:07|
|714 forum posts|
Veering a bit off topic, but still related to additives... when I was at polytechnic, one of our lecturers was heavily into researching cement additives, and had a number of examples of what was possible. The most impressive was a coil spring, made from sand, cement and additives, about six inches in diameter and height, probably about three turns, which acted in all respects just like a normal steel spring (possibly not as long a life though).
And the flat roof of a power station admin block I worked on had a foamed cement mix laid on top for insulation purposes - specialist mixers were used, don't know what the additive was.
Back on topic, yes, Fairy liquid works (never heard of it in concrete, only mortar), but builder's merchants don't sell it, so just order Feb whilst you're getting all the rest of your stuff delivered
|Mark Simpson 1||26/05/2021 11:26:17|
|103 forum posts|
There are additives for concrete to make them flow more easily when being pumped or into areas of dense reinforcement... Normally added once the mixer is still on site as it gets very sloppy.... Tarmac call it TOPFLOW, hanson call it easy flow... I had some awkward footings built with limited access and it saved us the cost of a concrete pump, just pulled it along with a rake.... Much preferred structurally to adding lots of water.
|Marischal Ellis||26/05/2021 11:48:36|
|74 forum posts|
Yes I too remember Daz in its powder form back in the sixties. Wasn't liked and would be restricted. I don't think too much would make a difference. Certainly helped to ease working the mortar, but that was alongside very hot bricks straight out the kiln and hosed down, dry sand lying in heaps on the ground and all sorts of other bad practises. Nobody seemed to care. Look at the London flat fire block proceedings 50 +years on......absolutely terrible. If you are responsible, then you are responsible, sharpens the mind no end. O dear perhaps I am too old now but have seen things that would make you seriously cringe. Stay safe everyone.
|Mike Poole||26/05/2021 11:49:29|
3075 forum posts
I have heard that washing up liquid can cause excessive corrosion of steel in concrete, this may be total rubbish as I have no authoritative source to quote and irrelevant if no reinforcement is used in the concrete.
|Grindstone Cowboy||26/05/2021 12:06:24|
|714 forum posts|
Seems feasible as there's a lot of salt in it to thicken it, but then again, cement is a bit on the corrosive side anyway. Some more so than others.
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.