By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Allendale Jan 24th

Music in the Workshop

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
Peter G. Shaw02/08/2020 11:15:13
avatar
1121 forum posts
44 photos

Hello folks,

I'm one of those who like to have ClassicFM burbling away in the background when in the workshop, and have noticed a change these last few months, indeed ClassicFM themselves are trumpeting that they have cut down on the chit-chat and upped the music. Great, I like it, although it does concern me a little bit about the costs of providing such a service without ads to pay for it. They have even started playing music without announcing it first, but I think they have always done that to a limited extent.

Anyway, yesterday, they surpassed themselves. About 16:20, they started playing Beethoven's 6th Symphony, The Pastoral, and they didn't finish until a little before 17:00 hours. Superb, the full symphony, uncluttered with extraneous unneeded comments, no ads, no break at 16:30, as the saying goes, The Full Monty. Absolutely wonderful to have such fine music filling the workshop. Thanks ClassicFM.

There is, for me anyway, a downside in that I find my attention drifting from the work in hand whilst I listen to the music which obviously delays completion of the project, but I wonder, do other people have this problem or is it just me?

There is, of course, some so-called clasical music which I do not like, eg Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue which I absolutely detest - it leaves me shaky, so much so that now I switch off the radio as soon as iI hear the introductory notes. I also find that some of this so-called English music, eg George Butterworth's Banks of Green Willows just boring, on the other hand Mozart cannot do any wrong.

What do other people think about classical music, pet hates & dislikes, and likes. Over to you.

Peter G. Shaw

Andrew Tinsley02/08/2020 11:32:08
1153 forum posts

I always listen to Radio 3. You don't get the interruptions and the music is better than the usual pop classics on Classic FM

Nothing wrong with Butterworth's Banks of green willow. If he hadn't been killed on the Somme I suspect that he would have produced music on a par with Elgar or even better.

As for Mozart "can do no wrong", well all I can say is that you have been very selective in the choice of his music. With such a vast catalogue, I can assure you that there are a good number of which are substandard.

Oh and I cannot stand Opera in any shape or form.

Andrew.

Edited By Andrew Tinsley on 02/08/2020 11:33:06

John Haine02/08/2020 11:34:41
3183 forum posts
172 photos

The Anvil Chorus? The variable cost of the Classic FM service is minimal really, it's all played out by a computer, they only need an announcer at home with an internet link.

Phil P02/08/2020 11:36:43
631 forum posts
166 photos

My wife has Classic FM on constantly in the house and insists having it on in the car as well.

I dont mind it too much, but when in the workshop it is usually Pink Floyd / David Gilmour or Supertramp.

Phil

Greensands02/08/2020 11:41:12
83 forum posts
5 photos

The only radio 'interference' permitted in the workshop can only be TMS as far as I am concerned and I am the boss in my workshop!

Bazyle02/08/2020 11:47:49
avatar
5296 forum posts
201 photos

What annoys me on all radio staions is the small playlist. Evein when they say they have hundreds it seems like the same thing comes on more than once a day, and I've even heard somone play a tune at the end of their shift only to have the next DJ play the same thing at the beginning of their run. Then with CFM they play only one version of a classic or just one song from a singer over and over. I suppose that is why you are supposed to buy the record (CD etc)

I agree with much of Peter's initial comments and am not keen on Gershwin or opera but can't be forever turning off as the radio is piped around the house from the living room. CFM does do 'full works concerts' most evenigs just not normally in the day.

A similar thread last month introduced me to Scala radio, just more difficult to get to without a preselect button.

Martin Kyte02/08/2020 11:51:26
avatar
1903 forum posts
34 photos

I'll second TMS, and I'll go on to say it gets better when it's raining.

regards Martin

John Haine02/08/2020 11:54:57
3183 forum posts
172 photos

I've recently invested in a subscription to iDagio - excellent.

Danny M2Z02/08/2020 11:58:02
avatar
871 forum posts
283 photos

When building a vintage '40's model aircraft with a spark ignition Ohlssen .23 it seemed appropriate to play "Glenn Miller's Greatest Hits" in the workshop. It got me 'In The Mood"

* Danny M *

KWIL02/08/2020 12:11:29
3264 forum posts
63 photos

Machine tool cutting is the best music in a workshop, definate no no to have a radio on.

John MC02/08/2020 12:17:13
avatar
293 forum posts
38 photos

I was once a Radio 1 listener, then the local independent station, now the local BBC station, a nice balance of chat and music. But, as Bazyle says, a limited playlist.

Having said that, its just in the background, listening with one ear, just occasionally something will interest me sufficiently to stop and listen properly!

John

Bob Stevenson02/08/2020 12:53:46
411 forum posts
6 photos

Interesting......

I greatly dislike nearly all singing...opera is a 'no-no' for me at all times......Having said that, I like 15thcentury church singing when cutting parts out with the piercing saw, my fave is Vespers Of 1610.......particularly nice when the rain is hitting the roof over the bench. For machine work I like Mahler...it's nice when you stop the lathe and the music drifts over the lathe.....

.......for 50 years I was in brass bands and have many CD's, vinyl and tapes etc...they are never in the workshop as they 'stop play' instantly!....But, I use Black Dyke playing Shostakovich 'Festival Overture' when something has gone badly, and 'Entry of The Gladiators' when it's been a disaster!

Brian H02/08/2020 13:13:19
avatar
1678 forum posts
109 photos

I,m with Kwil on this one; definitely no music or any other artificial sounds.

Brian

Sandgrounder02/08/2020 13:14:53
194 forum posts
6 photos
Posted by KWIL on 02/08/2020 12:11:29:

Machine tool cutting is the best music in a workshop, definate no no to have a radio on.

I'm exactly the same, with the exception of a car radio I don't listen to anything.

Graham Stoppani03/08/2020 09:37:36
avatar
76 forum posts
13 photos

I used to listen to Radio 6 in the workshop to break away from listening to what I already knew but found too many of the same songs repeating through the day. I now use a music streaming service on my phone with a bluetooth speaker.

I'm currently on a Frank Zappa marathon, listening to all his albums in chronological order. 62 albums release in his lifetime and another 50 posthumously...

SillyOldDuffer03/08/2020 09:38:29
5942 forum posts
1282 photos
Posted by Martin Kyte on 02/08/2020 11:51:26:

I'll second TMS, and I'll go on to say it gets better when it's raining.

regards Martin

From the BBC Radio 5-Live Extra schedule: 'A TMS listener explains why he got Alastair Cook's batting average as his first tattoo. '

(BBC Radio 5-Live specialises in Sports and TMS is 'Test Match Special', providing continuous live commentary on Test Cricket matches lasting up to 5 days. The commentary continues through 'Rain Stopped Play' and other interruptions, leading to humorous discussions about Seagulls, Cake, and outbreaks of hysteria. Here's an example. I guess it's the most difficult broadcasting challenge in the world. They aren't reading a TelePrompter! )

Dave

Hopper03/08/2020 10:21:07
avatar
4658 forum posts
101 photos

More likely to hear Jimi Hendrix or Joe Cocker in my shed thanks to Spotify streaming through wifi to my phone to a giant stereo  rescued from the scrap heap. Beautiful sound those big old speakers.

Edited By Hopper on 03/08/2020 10:23:25

Rik Shaw03/08/2020 10:59:49
avatar
1344 forum posts
364 photos

Any radio station that plays unusual / challenging music gets my vote. If it sees fit to air Penguin Cafe Orchestra or organ music by Lefebure Wely for instance I'm hooked. So goodbye Classic FM and hello to Scala Radio. I really needed to kick Classic FM into touch because of its moronic adverts (particularly the LV example) face 19 which has the same effect on me as as that hypocritical Lloyds bank TV advert --"By your side" . I'd prefer to have a large pile of steaming ordure by my side rather than THAT lot.

Rik (By gum I do feel better for that!)

R Johns03/08/2020 11:12:35
31 forum posts

For the last few months I have been turning away to Vera Lynn, other wartime music and Churchill's speeches.

IanT03/08/2020 11:21:45
1551 forum posts
144 photos

Both my Shops have radios pretty much permanently tuned to Classic FM - but I'm afraid that I don't consciously listen to the music really. It's more a background thing - plus an occasional reminder of the time (which can fly by unnoticed - leading to trouble with management)

I don't have the volume turned up and quite a lot of the time the machine noise will be drowning the radio out (especially when I put ear protectors on of course). More a habit I guess...

IanT

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
ChesterUK
EngineDIY
emcomachinetools
Allendale Electronics
Warco
cowells
Eccentric July 5 2018
Eccentric Engineering
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest