252 forum posts
Morning chaps. Whilst undertaking overdue spindle/bearing maintenace on my Myford ML7, I started to entertain the idea of a variable frequency (VFD) motor upgrade.
I've read a few posts in forums/youtube comments about the numerous benefits of replacing the original single phase motor (small-ish Metropolitan Vickers no less) with 3 phase VFD controlled. For starters:
Therefore I'm hoping for a concise summary of the advantges (and there any disadvantges, cost aside?) of this popular-ish upgrade. Please advise.
Thanks in advance.
|Nigel Graham 2||30/06/2020 02:21:03|
|667 forum posts|
I fitted my ML7 with a Newton-Tesla set, which is electronics plus motor.
My version is just a straight swap plus finding a suitable location for the inverter/controller. If you tell them the machine they know which electronics to pair with which motor.
I say "my version" - I'll go by that to start with. You'll see why, shortly.
The lead from the motor has a special plug for the connector on the electronics.
The main lead is rather short, at least on mine, so I have to use a short distribution-board. That though is a matter of workshop geography so may not apply to yours.
I placed the inverter on the cabinet below the headstock, but that is in the way of oil and swarf so I made it a cheap-and-cheerful plywood shelter that sits in the chip-tray above it. It's there because although I am right-handed, the disposition of the controls is better for using left-handed on the inverter I have. In particular, reducing the risk of accidentally using the wrong Stop button.
I stressed that clause because the Newton-Tesla systems I subsequently bought for my other machines differ, by having two separate electronics units. Those do need more wiring - not difficult if you are reasonably happy with such work; but it is vital you put the right wire in the right place, of the mains lead and of the cable linking the inverter itself to the control "pendant". Which isn't really a pendant but a box with lugs for screwing it to a surface.
If the set you buy is of that pattern, put the inverter somewhere well out of the way of swarf and oil-spray, as it is not fully-enclosed.
That on my Harrison lathe is high on the wall above the tail end of the bed, with the controller just below it, still well clear of the muck. It also keeps me clear of rotating things - which can't be said for the rather dubiously-designed clutch lever a feature of the L5! Similarly with the set on a BCA JIg-borer - on the wall a bit above and in front of my shoulder when sitting at the machine. The set destined for the milling-machine will also be similarly elevated to a higher plane.
One thing to watch (having just given myself an expensive repair!).....
If the motor is the type with open ventilation holes in its ends, fit a shield to protect it from swarf, unless your lathe already has that luxury. Turning some bronze, most of the swarf "corkscrews" were falling harmlessly to the front, and I failed to see one sneak round the rather inadequate shield, and enter the motor. The resulting short to earth did not hurt the motor but damaged the inverter. I can say N-T's repair service is prompt, but obviously equipment like this is not cheap!
While the motor and inverter were away I fabricated a complete back-panel and motor shield - I've put a photo of it on the "What I Did Today" thread.
Advantages? There are three, really.
- Very much smoother and quieter running than with the single-phase motor, which tends to make the cabinet (standard Myford one) resonate.
- Better speed control, especially for operations like screw-cutting up to a shoulder. By still using the back-gear, you can have everything moving at a less nerve-wracking rate.
- Ability to adjust the speed during the cut, as sometimes useful such as when noise or chatter may indicate wrong speed for the other conditions. Also when paring-off large diameters.
NB: 1. These motors do not like being run too slowly, and the warning colours on the speed control are for low as well as excessive speed. (Used in conjunction with the headstock gears, I can run the Harrison at about 60rpm with the motor still happy at nearly 1000 rpm.)
NB 2: Don't use the Emergency stop-button as normal stop. The makers warn its frequent use can harm the electronics.
I've not found any.
So, I hope this answers your query!
|Ray Lyons||30/06/2020 07:39:58|
|166 forum posts|
I went the cheap way of installing a VDF on my Super 7 about 15 years ago. Bought a used Lens controller on eBay for about £5 and a new 1HP 3P motor. A bit of a tight squeeze getting the motor in but just fitted. Fitted the unit on the wall behind the lathe and brought a remote control to the leg of the bench.
Agree with everything Nigel has written about the advantages and would add that in my case with the S7 clutch and gearbox it is a step change over the old drive. The larger motor enables the speed changing to be kept to a minium I put the drive belt in the middle range and have not had to change it for years.
|Robert Atkinson 2||30/06/2020 20:33:47|
698 forum posts
This is just based on review of the material on the Newton-Tesla website, but their ML7 Super7 prewired kits look quite good. They appear to have the inverter in a proper enclosure which is a safety requirement and not met by just buing an inverter, Chinese or otherwise. It also comes properly set up for the motor. Unless you are reasonbly skille with electrical systems I'd strongly recommend buying a pre-made unit like their AV750.
|1541 forum posts|
Both the .5hp and the 1hp motors for Myford on the Tesla site are vented motors, not the ideal choice for a machine that's making swarf and chips, better to have a totally enclosed fan cooled version IMO.
|Harry Wilkes||30/06/2020 21:34:58|
926 forum posts
Fit a Transwave kit on my S7 couple years back the only problem I had was removing the motor pulley, I purchased a remote control unit for the VFD I collected it from Transwave as it was not that far the whole lot came with idiot proof installation guide. I have the expertise to have purchased motor and VFD independantly and made up a remote unit but I didn't have the time and to be honest the inclination to source the parts.
|Alan Gordon 4||02/07/2020 06:43:11|
|91 forum posts|
I fitted the Tesla CL unit four years ago with absolutely no problems.
Just recently however despite having a perspex guard ( which i made) over the rear of the motor a small amount of swarf manage to get into the motor. I contact Tesla and took advice on how to strip down and clean out the motor, I have to say that the advice and help received was excellent resulting in the motor being stripped and cleaned (easy job) I guess this is the advantage in buying from "local" company. When i bought the unit it came with 10 year guarantee on the electronics don't know if this still applies though.
1262 forum posts
The 3ph motor on my S7 is from Clarks machine mart. There is a cooling fan & guard, but the motor is sealed. The fan is only blowing on the casting. A few times a bit of swarfe has found it's way in there & rattled about before getting spit out. I now have a bit of hardboard bent around the back to stop this. A bit tacky, i need to make something better. When i fitted this setup it was not too expensive. From memory the whole thing with my own made panel / inverter & motor was around £250. Picture of my setup.
|Nigel Graham 2||03/07/2020 01:06:45|
|667 forum posts|
I think I am right in saying that Newton-Tesla do now sell totally-enclosed motors for the Myford lathes (or presumably any lathe).
It did surprise me though that whilst the first set I bought - for the ML7 - has a fully-enclosed inverter / controller (it has vents but at the back of the box and fitted with internal mesh) the sets I bought later for other machines all have separate inverters and controllers, and the former are not all that well enclosed. I think they are really designed to be fitted inside cabinets.
|Philip Burley||03/07/2020 08:32:55|
185 forum posts
The motor on my S7 gave up the ghost a couple of years ago and I fitted the newton tesla kit . No problems whatever and much better to use than the single phase motor , ( mind you that was goodness knows how old ) For screw cutting , it.s great using the "jog" control and easy reversing . I would recommend it ( not cheap however )
|Andrew Moyes 1||03/07/2020 18:14:57|
|114 forum posts|
I fitted Newton Tesla plug-and-play VFD packages to both my ML7 metalwork and ML8 woodwork lathes. That on the ML8 developed a fault after a couple of years; the speed potentiometer became noisy and the speed became uncontrollable. I took the sealed unit in person to the firm in Warrington and was told that the 10-year guarantee only applied to the inverter and not the peripheral switches and potentiometer. I was asked to pay £26 for the repair. So much for the 10-year guarantee, which I notice they still advertise without any qualification. I would normally replace a noisy potentiometer myself but as it was a sealed unit (pop rivetted), I didn’t want to invalidate the guarantee on the Mitsubishi inverter, so I paid up. Having paid over the odds for the complete package, I was not happy.
|not done it yet||17/07/2020 11:47:34|
|4734 forum posts|
When i bought the unit it came with 10 year guarantee on the electronics don't know if this still applies though.
I expect it does - for another ~6years? Unless the company stops trading....
|Robert Atkinson 2||17/07/2020 12:18:47|
698 forum posts
That is not an example of correct installaton To comply with good practice, the installation manual and current regulations the inverter drive needs to be in an enclosure and cables should have proper strain reliefs as a minmum. It should probably have EMI filters too . I alse note the use of an unsafe and illegal adaptor with a 2 pin european style plug in it on he lower power strip. Cut the two pin plug off, smash it and the adaptor and put a proper 13A plug with a 3 A or 5 A in it on the lead.
|A Smith||17/07/2020 13:13:37|
|40 forum posts|
Myford 3ph Motor Guard om my ML7. Slightly dodgy gas welding but does the job. Motor now 6 years old, nothing ingested that has made itself known.
Edited By JasonB on 17/07/2020 13:36:37
|not done it yet||17/07/2020 13:36:22|
|4734 forum posts|
... If you wish to carry on like that it's up to you.
Agreed, but poor showing to put that sort of thing on a video or pic that others, less well informed, might copy - unless, of course it is flagged up as p poor practice by the video/pic provider. Too many, out there in the real world don’t think before copying that sort of thing.
|Maurice Taylor||17/07/2020 13:49:42|
|95 forum posts|
If the European adapter is illegal ,why is it on sale still and made to BS5733/A ?
2 pin European plugs with bare cable ends are also on sale
|Robert Atkinson 2||17/07/2020 18:35:42|
698 forum posts
That particular adaptor is illegal. part from quality I can tell from the picture that it's not wide enough. This means you can pluld one pin in with the othar hnging over the side. If the pin is in the live side there is a circuit through the load to the pin on the side maiking it live. so the lod does not work so you reach to check the adaptor, touch the exposed pin and get a shock, possibly fatal.
BS 5733 is not directly relevent, travel adaptors are covered by BS 8546.
Just because you can buy something dosen't mean it's safe or legal for a particular application. For example non-uk mains leads are use by companies making equipmeent for export. One compny I worked for got a PAT operative in over the weekend and he cut the plugs off 10 machines waiting to go to the USA and fitted 13A ones. He did not get paid!
Edited By Robert Atkinson 2 on 17/07/2020 18:39:44
Edited By Robert Atkinson 2 on 17/07/2020 18:40:13
1262 forum posts
Well here goes. Robert Atkinson you are a miss informed individual. You keep posting on this site as if you are some sort of Oracle. I know all. I guess you read too much. I have in my career as an an industrial electrical contractor, fitted somewhere in the region of 300 inverters & built some 200 control panels, including designing them with approval from the the engineering departments that ordered them. Nestle, / Fox's biscuits,/Terry's York,/Harrods biscuit manufacturer (cannot name. NDA. Trebor Bassets,/ Haribo. All blue chip companies.
Having worked in the industry all my life i have come across people like yourself a few times. What am i talking about you may ask.
You should fit a inverter VFD in an enclosure. It is in an enclosure. There is no requirement to fit a inverter inside a box. It is in a box. Strain relief. Strain relief from what. It is a fixed appliance. My god you get worse. I take it you do not travel around the world as i do. The euro adaptor is from Boots. Fitting sockets behind a spinning lathe chuck,,, disaster. No actually i removed the swarf shield to show the equipment.
I think you may only have 7 fingers & 2 thumbs. I am guessing where the missing finger is.
You should maybe also have an EMI filter fitted. ?????? Why. We only fitted filters in panels that had PLC equipment in them, or sensitive electronics, like RS 232 interfaces or sensitive encoders. You really need to stick to flying model planes. You have NO PROFFESIONAL OBLIGATION or knowledge to be making the recommendations or assumptions that you are doing.
If someone puts a post on this forum requiring help. If i have the knowledge i will reply & try to help. Some folk seem to think they know everything & reply to things that maybe they should not. That is why a lot of the very experienced forum members do not reply any more. I have quite a few private mails from some of them.
I do not know why this keeps happening & can only assume that there are some sad individuals , or may be envious individuals who cannot afford some of the toy's that others have.
If a member of this site asks about a depth of cut, Or a way of soldering the tubes in a boiler, i would not reply because i do not have the knowledge to do so.
Steve. & proud
|781 forum posts|
You should fit a inverter VFD in an enclosure. It is in an enclosure. There is no requirement to fit a inverter inside a box. It is in a box.
As shown, that inverter is not "in a box" or an enclosure, it is just mounted on a wall, unprotected, in a vulnerable location.
Omron describe that inverter as being an "open chassis" in the drive manual & say that it should be protected from (amongst other things) dust & metallic particles, oil mists and not in direct sunlight. That suggests to me that it should be mounted in a suitable enclosure - same as other inverters I have used. The manual also suggests the use of an input line reactor to improve power factor & a suitable input filter to reduce interference "if required" - which suggests that appropriate testing of the installation is required to determine if a filter is required. Presumably you did suitable testing & found that these were not required in this case ?
The above is not an opinion - it is all in the Omron VS mini J7 installation and operating manual. Did you really just screw inverters to the wall like that for Nestle etc. ?
|1541 forum posts|
The VFD is contained in an IP20 enclosure and there is no instruction in the makers manual to fit in any further enclosure. The picture was taken with the chip guard removed from the back of the lathe for clarity.
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.