|Matt Harrington||13/12/2019 18:16:49|
119 forum posts
Brian, I think I have one of those somewhere - will expeiment over the next few days.
|Matt Harrington||13/12/2019 18:24:36|
119 forum posts
Robert, I'm in Sout Somerset, near to Yeovil.
|Clive Foster||13/12/2019 20:39:44|
|1950 forum posts|
Unfortunately a clamp on current meter hitched to a multimeter won't be fast enough to properly register the start up current surge.
Need a proper data logging system for that to plot a current against time as the motor runs up with reasonable resolution.
Grossly oversimplifying things the internal control electronics of a VFD used as a Digital Phase Converter will be looking at the rate of change of the output current when the motor is switched on and the rate at which the capacitor bank discharges. If they are too high it thinks you have a short circuit and shuts the VFD down. For obvious reasons this process is fast, very fast. Equally obviously the higher power the VFD is the more current it has to be programmed to source before it decides there really is a short on the output and deciding to shut down. Which is a major reason why you need such a big one.
Its annoying that no one makes a device behaving like the Eaton DE-1 series variable speed starter units having a voltage doubling input and proper programming for the job. Real 3 hp (ish) start, 3 hp drive, one probably do-able for £200 or so. OK it would take about 2 seconds to run the motor up, which matters not a jot.
Sell like hot cakes.
I'll have ten thanks!
Perhaps £30 extra for a box with stop start buttons and either a two speed switch or a knob with a dial to vary speed by 30% or so would go down well too. I wouldn't need it but many would. Wire one end to the mains, one end to the motor and Bobs your Uncle, Sally's your Aunt.
|Robert Atkinson 2||13/12/2019 21:10:25|
463 forum posts
Sorry, too far for me, Cambrdge.
|Robert Atkinson 2||13/12/2019 21:25:42|
463 forum posts
Edited By Robert Atkinson 2 on 13/12/2019 21:32:19
|Matt Harrington||14/12/2019 10:51:41|
119 forum posts
Clive, there's a new venture for you!!
|larry phelan 1||14/12/2019 11:37:29|
|563 forum posts|
I am surprised that the noise from the rotary converter is that bad. I have a 7.5 KVA unit and I don't find it too noisy, but then, I half deaf anyway, thanks to noisy conditions in a past life [Anyone else been there ? ]
Yes there is a some noise from them, but I built a cover around mine and can live with it.
Better than listening to S-W-M-B-O ,and can be switched off !!
|Bob Worsley||14/12/2019 17:00:04|
|7 forum posts|
Interesting, not come across a digital phase converter before, but then I have three phase in the house.
As has been mentioned just seem to be a standard VFD with a voltage booster on the input. This is both a tribute to the amazing electrolytic capacitors now available, and a problem.
To step 220V up to 440V needs a capacitor, it is charged to peak volts on the negative half or the sine wave, and then lifted up to charge the output capacitor on the positive peak of the sine wave. This is identical to the dual voltage switch mode power supplies that have been around for years. The snag comes because the output capacitor is only charged once per cycle, so 50 times per second. And that charge is just a rapid dump of charge from the input capacitor to the output capacitor. If the VFD is running 5hp, then that is 3730W, divided by 0.9 pf divided by 0.9 efficiency giving 4600W. So this 4600W for one cycle needs to be dumped in the output cap in about 5ms to run the motor for the 20ms cycle. Simply put if the motor takes 10A then this current is 40A.
Certainly works the caps hard.
You can emulate this with a standard 400V 3ph VFD, the few I have seen all have terminals on the back to add in extra smoothing caps. Just make your own voltage doubler and attach the output cap to these terminals. It is seriously lethal, so perhaps not.
An induction motor will take an 8x overload to start. Don't forget that all that is limiting the current is the synchronous impedance of the motor. This is why a 5kW generator won't start a 3hp compressor. To some extent it is relying on the inertia of the rotor to keep turning to get the voltage regulator to crank up the excitation current.
If the rotary converter is noisy then switch the motor off as soon as the lathe is running, not then needed provided you check that there is enough running capacitance to keep the phases reasonably at 120 degrees.
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.