A bit of a disaster
|Martin Johnson 1||26/02/2019 08:31:19|
|116 forum posts|
I have just had to abandon four cylinder drain cocks, which were to be silver soldered assemblies. I had some "Unicast Holfos B" in stock for the bodies and had intended to silver solder in some brass connections. Suffice to say that after a couple of attempts the solder just does not want to wet the bronze. On the second attempt, I pickled the bronze bodies for a couple of days - after which they were BLACK. My chemistry is not great, but I wonder if Holos B contains lead?
Holfos B is an old specification (I can remember it but don't have any reliable information on the chemical analysis - but guessing the "....fos" is phosphor.
To avoid clogging this thread with the obvious suggestions, I have been model engineering for 50 years now, so have done a bit of silver soldering along the way.
So - are there certain grades of bronze that are best avoided for silver soldering? And if so, what others (apart from Holfos B) should be avoided, as quite a few contain lead? Or maybe this is just a one off disaster?
Hoping to be enlightened.
|Michael Gilligan||26/02/2019 08:38:36|
13551 forum posts
I think you are probably on the right track, Martin
Have a look at pp554-555 here: **LINK**
Edited By Michael Gilligan on 26/02/2019 08:39:49
|not done it yet||26/02/2019 08:42:51|
|3148 forum posts|
Can't help with your silver soldering. Only suggest using locktite (or equivalent) instead?
15743 forum posts
Michael's link shows no lead percentage, SA660 and LG1 contain lead and they can be silver soldered so not sure if that is the reason.
Edited By JasonB on 26/02/2019 08:45:56
Edited By JasonB on 26/02/2019 10:41:41
|CuP Alloys 1||26/02/2019 09:48:46|
192 forum posts
Silver solder not wetting is always a flux problem. Silver solder not flowing can be due to heat pattern, joint gap, flux or contamination eg lead from a bronze.
Give us a call for more information. It's a quicker and easier way to communicate than the forum.
Looking forward to hearing from you.
|Martin Johnson 1||26/02/2019 16:19:09|
|116 forum posts|
Michael G - Thanks for the link. It looks as though Holfos B is a tin bronze 88 Cu / 11.7Sn, with 0.7% P so it should be OK. I had looked on Google but you are clearly a better man than I, Gungadin.
But that leaves a mystery as to what had turned it black in my H2SO4 pickle. And as a consequence, the female threads which (should) hold the brass tails were not as clean as I would have liked, but I threw plenty of flux at it just in case.
Thanks Keith for that. I am trying to join quite small brass tails onto a relatively chunky bronze body - so that might be it. Anyway, I now need some more silver solder so will indeed give you a ring.
1582 forum posts
You left it in the pickle too long...had it happen to me. No telling what went into making your bronze but it will and does turn black. Ive had brass do it as well. Get a bit of Tenicity 5 flux, mix it thick and it should work fine on clean metal. You need the extra temp flux due to the small piece of work getting hotter quicker. Good luck.
|mark costello 1||26/02/2019 18:32:48|
529 forum posts
As I have followed the forum for a while the problem of a flux not lasting long enough comes up regularly. Why even use the lower grade at all? Just go for the strongest at the get go.
Edited By mark costello 1 on 26/02/2019 18:33:13
|Nigel Graham 2||16/03/2019 22:59:04|
|351 forum posts|
Re original: "what other" bronzes to avoid!
Beware of Aluminium Bronze, widely used for marine equipment thanks to its very high corrosion resistance. Drills bind it for a pastime, but more pertinently here, it will not take conventional lead/tin and silver solders.
Polished, it has a rather paler than normal brass colour, which helps to differentiate it from other cuprous alloys.
How do I know? Guess! One of the hazards of the Pre-loved Metals bin...
|CuP Alloys 1||21/03/2019 15:51:36|
192 forum posts
At the risk of repeating myself, if the silver solder or soft solder doesn't "wet" you have a flux problem.
Use the right flux.
Aluminium alloys can be soft soldered.
Aluminium bronzes can be readily silver soldered.
Ring us for more information.
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.