By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Allendale Nov 29

Vertex BS-0 Dividing Head 1-1/8 BSW Myford Spindle Nose

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
Michael O'Connor08/02/2019 18:10:06
13 forum posts
16 photos

Hello,

I just purchased a Vertex BS-0 Dividing Head with the 1-1/8”-12 BSW Myford spindle nose from Rotagrip. Wanted the capability to transfer the chucks and other spindle tooling from my Myford S7 to a dividing head directly. Because I live in the USA and returning this would be very expensive, I emailed and spoke with Rotagrip directly to make sure this model would have a Myford spindle nose. They assured me it does indeed.

Upon inspection, it does have the correct thread and a spot on 1.250” register diameter. Spindle is heat treated and the threads and register are ground. Threads need to be deburred at both ends, but everything is in order. Except the distance from the end of the spindle to the register shoulder. The Myford lathe spindle is a nominal 1” length and the dividing head is 0.865” or approximately 1/8” shorter.

c7fad8fa-d2dc-4afa-93bc-a8ce2d722103.jpeg

3ba25f81-f567-44a8-ae69-80fa980017d3.jpeg

The problem with the missing 1/8” of thread is that the Myford Burnerd chucks, faceplates, etc. only engage 2-1/4 turns. With a thread lead of 0.083”, that is only 3/16” of thread engagement. With a hardened D/H spindle thread and cast iron chuck backplates, that could be a potential problem with cracking or failure of the cast iron internal threads.

My questions to other BS-0 D/H owners: Are your D/H spindles 7/8” long and has this ever been an issue for you?

Another odd thing with this unit is that it came with a lathe dog, I am guessing, instead of a proper dog driver. See photos below. The 2MT center has the short parallel diameter to attach the dog driver. Not a big deal to make one, just curious that it wasn’t included. The blank chuck backplate has a 1.250” register diameter that is too short to be mounted on the Myford lathe spindle but it doesn’t have a slot to drive the supplied lathe dog. Any work dog would need to be held captive on a D/H, so that probably isn’t what was intended. Have other owners received a proper dog driver?

Ian at Rotagrip told me this model of BS-0 (Model T) has been discontinued and he believes this was the last one he had in stock. I wanted to ask of others experiences with this model before contacting Rotagrip.

Thanks for taking a look.

Regards,

Mike

23325056-e9c0-4327-af87-71164f64a4f7.jpeg

a0711d07-20e1-498f-9188-3ee7276917e5.jpeg

lfoggy08/02/2019 19:10:24
28 forum posts
5 photos

I bought one of these from Rotagrip a few months ago but mine was the type where the chuck bolts onto a backplate fixed to the 2MT spindle. Like you, I received a lathe dog and the centre like in your picture but I didn’t get the dog driver. This puzzled me as well.

Your spindle issue must be very annoying, but I think you would easily get away with using your Myford chucks on this short spindle nose. If you are using the device for indexing, then the forces on the chuck and the mounting will be much less than on a lathe. I would be more worried about unscrewing of the chuck occurring with uneven cutting forces of milling etc.

I am very pleased with mine. It’s lovely to use, accurate and rigid. Was using it to cut some gears earlier today in fact. The only mod I have made is a little detent to hold the plunger back on the indexing device which makes using it a bit more convenient.

Baz08/02/2019 19:43:36
147 forum posts

I purchased a similar BS-0 dividing head about ten years ago, I cannot remember who supplied it but it is identical to yours so they have been supplied with that spindle nose for quite a few years. I feel that they should be advertised as similar to Myford because it is most certainly not a Myford spindle nose. I have used Myford chucks without any problem but have not heaved them up very tight because of the minimal engagement. I also remember that the internal taper was described as brown and sharpe taper, not morse but don’t know how true this is, I have never used a centre in the head itself. I have recently fitted a chuck to the supplied thin backplate so I now have a dedicated for the head, I made a thin plastic washer and put that on the Myford lathe spindle and then screwed the chuck backplate up tight against it, not ideal but good enough to machine the chuck register.

Tony Pratt 108/02/2019 20:26:51
812 forum posts
2 photos

My BS0 D/H spindle is just the same as yours, no problem after ten years, not really sure why they didn't just copy the Myford nose?

Tony

Saxalby08/02/2019 20:32:05
148 forum posts
13 photos

Again bought my BS-0 about ten or so years ago and it has a 2 mt spindle. Have never had a problem with an attached Myford chucks even with heavy milling cuts.

Also made a Myford to Boxford spindle adapter to use the Boxfords chucks.

John Olsen08/02/2019 20:41:40
928 forum posts
86 photos
1 articles

My Vertex BS0, purchased about 40 years ago by my father, has a threaded nose that is not Myford, and has the Brown and Sharp taper. Since then they have changed the thread, and I think possibly some also have the Morse taper.

No matter what the thread or taper, I think the nose setup is wrong. Experience tells me that under even light milling loads, the drive plate or chuck can move on the thread, and the driver that clamps onto the taper can turn the taper in the socket. Not to be trusted. I have drilled the small end of the centre so that a draw bar can be used. I also made a backplate to suit so that I can use a spare chuck, but it would be nicer if I could turn a job on the Myford and then just transfer the chuck or faceplate over to the dividing head.

John

Michael O'Connor08/02/2019 21:05:28
13 forum posts
16 photos

Thank you Ifoggy, Baz, Tony, Saxalby and John for your replies. Much appreciated!

In the past, I had a Vertex BS-0 that had an 1-1/2”-8 UN spindle, which is what they sell in North America. That one had a No.7 B&S spindle taper. The Brown & Sharpe spindle taper was traditionally used in the past for dividing heads. I have a much larger Ellis D/H that I use on my Bridgeport milling machine. It is 1950’s vintage and has a No.9 B&S taper in the spindle nose. I think Vertex and others originally used the B&S taper in their B&S D/H copies but recently changed to Morse taper because of the difficulty in sourcing B&S tooling these days and the Morse taper tooling is so much more common. Try to find an ER collet chuck with a B&S taper. Maybe they actually listened to their customers feedback. Makes more sense anyway.

Totally aware of the threaded chuck unscrewing potential problem. Wouldn’t use this D/H for heavy milling. Mostly second operation work like drilling, milling flats and gear cutting. With the limited thread engagement, only light duty work would be attempted. Mainly wanted a smaller D/H to use on a smaller Rockwell horizontal milling machine I have. The table is only 6”x 24” and my Ellis D/H is a bit too big for it especially if there a setup that requires a foot stock (tailstock).

Thanks again for the replies!

Edited By Michael O'Connor on 08/02/2019 21:31:40

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
Warco
ChesterUK
Eccentric July 5 2018
Ausee.com.au
Eccentric Engineering
emcomachinetools
Allendale Electronics
Sarik
TRANSWAVE Converters
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest