|andrew lyner||08/01/2019 12:05:54|
|117 forum posts|
The site is a real gem and I have found it very helpful and useful. Nice members all over the place.
There are a number of ways in which actually using the Forum could be improved and which would bring it up to the level of the other,' better' forums I use. (The ergonomics not the people and the info)
One really confusing thing is how the Return key takes you back to the top of the page. I don't know where that feature came from but I haven't come across it before in my twenty years of Internet use. Could that be changed, without costing an arm and a leg?
Andrew (and I just did it again!!!!)
|John Hinkley||08/01/2019 12:15:38|
741 forum posts
Andrew - are you using an iPad or other Apple machine? I find I get the same result as you with the return key, but only when using the iPad. It's perfectly "normal" on my PC with Windows 7 pro.
I may have misunderstood your comment about multiple quotes, but there is the facility import sections of another's post already incorporated within the forum. Use the ""Quote at the bottom of the post from which you wish to quote. I can't see why you wouldn't be able to do that multiple times.
|andrew lyner||08/01/2019 12:28:59|
|117 forum posts|
I use an iMac with the Apple bluetooth keyboard. It talks correctly to all my other software and on all websites that I use. This is the only site where Return gives you a return and then Home. It can't be hard to fix and just has to be an anomaly of the site. I am surprised that no one else has found the problem with an Apple / Unix Desktop machine. There must be some US members with Apple, even if the UK members all use PCs.
On quotes: if you quote a post, it seems to put a copy of the post in a new edit window. Going to another post and pressing 'quote' starts a new edit window (losing your original text) and puts that quoted post in it. On other forums I use, you can highlight a passage and 'quote' it - then another and another. The quotes are stored and you can insert them, putting comments between each quote. Alternatively you can pick and insert quotes one at a time into existing text. It's really very useful on some threads where a number of different people are presenting arguments.
I don't know how long ago the forum software was installed but it could definitely benefit from a bit of an upgrade.
2432 forum posts
… "One really confusing thing is how the Return key takes you back to the top of the page"...
16005 forum posts
The return key issue has been ongoing for several years and affects some Mac users, I think there is a way round it but not being a Mac user I don'r remember it. It is not an easy fix otherwise it would have been done.
The forum software used here is different to a lot of other forums as it has to incorporate subscribers sections, adverts etc that you don't get on a lot of other ME forums and is not likely to be changed any time soon.
The last time the "like" subject came up I think the majority did not want it.
|Neil Wyatt||08/01/2019 13:50:40|
16423 forum posts
I regularly offer my advice on what the 'next generation' forum software should be like.
The return issue seems to have arrived as a result of a change in how apple devices work. It's unlikely to be fixed until we change the system at some point in the future.
|andrew lyner||08/01/2019 17:01:08|
|117 forum posts|
I know that there are differences in the codes but, as I have pointed out, the problem never arises anywhere else and it should really be up to the writer of the (minority) software for the forum editor. Windows, throughout its history, has been littered with this compatibility thing and a lot of it goes back to the DOS Operating System . Apple software has its quirks too and there's been what amounted to hostility between Microsoft and Apple at times. But this Return issue has been solved time after time elsewhere. Cntrl Return does the job for me but it's just an on-going niggle.
|Grizzly bear||08/01/2019 17:12:33|
|200 forum posts|
Same problem here on Win10.
My solution; Just keep typing, then back peddle to where you want the new line/paragraph.
Then hit 'Return'.
|Dave Halford||08/01/2019 17:18:41|
|438 forum posts|
I get the return issue on my PC Win 10 and I'm pretty sure I did on my old Win 7 machine too.
|Bill Phinn||08/01/2019 17:23:55|
|194 forum posts|
Yes, I too find the quoting facility unusually inconvenient. On the rare occasions I've wanted to multiquote, I've opened new edit boxes in new windows, copied the quoted text from them, closed these boxes, then pasted the new material into the original edit box. If someone can suggest a quicker solution, I'd be grateful.
I'm glad "likes" are not a part of this forum. They can certainly be useful in signalling helpful or interesting comments, but too often they are simply a way of expressing personal loyalties or disloyalties, as the case may be, and as a result can create even wider discord and divisions than may exist already.
|4590 forum posts|
Not making excuses for the quirky forum but Apple's Return/Enter eccentricity has certainly caused trouble elsewhere - Facebook being one example.
More chance of getting a fix if large numbers of users are inconvenienced. Unfortunately I don't suppose iPads are popular with forum members many of whom seem to prefer Windows XP!
Anyhoo, it's the Browser (Safari?) that negotiates with the Web Server to decide how your device will be handled, not the operating system or the hardware. Try querying this website to get your Browser Identification String. Mine is "Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Ubuntu; Linux x86_64; rv:64.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/64.0". Sometimes they're corrupt. It's possible to change the identification string at the user end, for example, when Internet Exploder was king I sometimes told fuss-pot microsoft-centric websites I was running Windows just to keep them happy. (Such tricks are rarely necessary these days.)
However, easier to try another browser (Chrome, Firefox, Puffin, Dolphin, Perfect etc. ) than to mess with settings - you can always uninstall should it not fix the problem.
The forum software is fine once you get over the initial culture shock! (Posting photos is fun too.) Persist - I feel the content matters far more than the presentation.
Edited By SillyOldDuffer on 08/01/2019 17:55:29
|Michael Gilligan||08/01/2019 18:10:04|
13789 forum posts
As invited, Dave:
|Chris Trice||08/01/2019 18:12:19|
1362 forum posts
Agree. I would snip the middle of the quote but fear I'd then have to chase the cursor all around the page trying to get it back in the right place to make this comment.
|Harry Wilkes||08/01/2019 18:19:29|
699 forum posts
Have the same problem with the return key on win10 however if I hold down the Ctrl key then hit return the cursor goes to it normal place
|Neil Wyatt||08/01/2019 18:30:20|
16423 forum posts
It's not written in house, it's off-the-shelf editor software which may make updating more difficult than if it was a bespoke solution.
852 forum posts
For Apple, mine is a MacBook just press Shift & Return to move down -- return twice if you want an extra line space
|827 forum posts|
John - thanks, that (Shift & Return) works a treat, much better than typing on then going back to where you want the break and then 'returning'!
|2205 forum posts|
If this forum complied with accepted standards it should work fine with all the common platforms, Windows, Apple, Google, Android etc. The internet is not just for Microsoft users. The fact is this has always been the worst forum software I've used apart from Google Groups. I Never have the problems I get on here with any other site. Some of the forums I visit clearly use the same basic software package and work very well. When IT related things haven't worked properly in some of my past jobs it's often been down to lack of investment, poor staff or both.
|andrew lyner||08/01/2019 23:01:07|
|117 forum posts|
What a good idea. I will try it.
Amazing that I haven't coma across that particular Return problem with any other software. At least, not consciously. There is a sort of problem with some of the 'media' when a Return will launch your post and not go to a new line but I just put it down to a programmer's choice between hard and soft break. At least the result leaves the cursor in a position to type on a new line.
I just did it AGAIN!!!! I will experiment with browsers.
|andrew lyner||08/01/2019 23:10:09|
|117 forum posts|
Well dang me - it's OK on Firefox.
Cheers my boy
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.