By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Allendale Nov 29

DC motors

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
Gordon W19/07/2018 11:02:24
2005 forum posts

I have two motors, both 24V DC, 250W, 14 Amps, 2500 rpm. These are permanent magnet 4 brush. Question is can these be connected in series to run on 48V ? It seems obvious that they can and will work ok but I'm losing confidence. Also can a cheap 48v speed controller be used ?

Norman Billingham19/07/2018 11:32:46
17 forum posts

I'm no expert on motors but I suspect not as a general rule. If the two motors are connected in series then the same current must flow in each of them. If they always have exactly the same load then that might work, but if the load on one changes then the current it draws must change and that must surely affect the other motor?

john swift 119/07/2018 11:36:02
avatar
310 forum posts
175 photos

It may be possible

but it depends on the motors being identical and the mechanical load on the motors being the same

 

my instinct is to use a 24V supply and a separate speed control for each motor

 

what are you wanting to do with the motors ?

If its some kind of electric vehicle is it possible to have the motors driving the same drive shaft ?

 

John

 

Edited By john swift 1 on 19/07/2018 11:36:58

James Jenkins 119/07/2018 11:42:54
avatar
112 forum posts

Just going to jump in here and say that having gone through "cheap" import speed controllers, I now use these ones:

**LINK**

and find them to be very good.

James

Gordon W19/07/2018 11:51:03
2005 forum posts

Thanks- that was quick. It's for vehicle use, hopefully, They will be coupled together mechanically, both driving the same shaft via chain coupling, so should have same load and current draw. Motors are identical, off mini scooters, and are like new inside. The use of cheap controllers is noted, good advice I think.

John Haine19/07/2018 12:06:03
2191 forum posts
126 photos

Since they are connected "in parallel" mechanically, they should also be in parallel electrically, not in series. If you then drive from a single 24V speed controller, they will see the same terminal voltage and want to run at the same speed, assuming they are more or less matched.

Roger B19/07/2018 12:16:16
avatar
49 forum posts
13 photos

If the loads can be well balanced series connection could work. If you go to worst case and have one motor jammed and the other free the free motor will get most of the 48V.

Series / parallel switching of motors was (is?) used in full sized traction but these motors had series field windings. The permanent magnet motors you have are closer to shunt field motors.

Best regards

Roger

Ron Laden19/07/2018 12:31:13
685 forum posts
99 photos

Gordon, I,m curious, how are you supplying 48 volts. Most 24 volt motors are run on 24 volt from 2 x 12 volt batteries wired in series, unless you are running 4 x 12 volt of course.

Ron

Edited By Ron Laden on 19/07/2018 12:42:00

Michael Gilligan19/07/2018 13:09:04
avatar
12061 forum posts
525 photos
Posted by Gordon W on 19/07/2018 11:51:03:

Thanks- that was quick. It's for vehicle use, hopefully, They will be coupled together mechanically, both driving the same shaft via chain coupling, so should have same load and current draw.

.

Please forgive me for leaping in without any detailed knowledge of your proposed vehicle, Gordon

Have you considered the possibility of two half-shafts; each driven via a freewheel unit, by its own motor ?

... This produces a low cost drivetrain that roughly approximates a differential.

MichaelG.

Gordon W19/07/2018 14:00:49
2005 forum posts

Michael- my original idea was 2 half-shafts. I decided on 48 v just to half the current and still get some power. The 48 v will be from 4x 12v lead acid batteries ( I have a mate who gets these trade) As usual with me cost is the deciding factor. I have two good motors, why buy another one? I must admit that buying 2 new motors and using half -shafts and using 48v is sensible. Thanks for the ideas.

Ron Laden19/07/2018 15:18:16
685 forum posts
99 photos

Gordon,

I would wire the motors from the controller in parallel and run at 24 volts but thats just me, I dont like the idea of wiring them in series but you can of course. Why do you want to half the current..? its not as if its particularly high from the figures you have given. Also running at 24 volt saves the cost of 2 batteries when cost is a deciding factor. Also I dont know if this is a loco or another type of vehicle but depending on the 12 volt battery type 16 to 18 kgs each so a saving of over 30 kgs with 2 batteries instead of 4.

Sorry it sounds as if I am picking faults but I,m not its just that I cant see the benefit of going 4 batteries (cost/weight) - 48 volts and wiring in series. The motors you are using are the same type and model so wiring in parallel the motors will be fine they dont need to be identical, they will be close enough and will work ok.

Re cheap speed controllers, well I have one (Chinese) off Ebay for £15 (40amp) running 4 motors in parallel on the 0-4-0 I am building. It works but yes it has crossed my mind will it burn out or give up once it is working under load but at £15 it has to be worth a try. The link to the better controller on an earlier post is according to the spec "non reversible" by the way so if you need reverse on your vehicle the controller shown is not the one.

regards

Ron

 

Edited By Ron Laden on 19/07/2018 15:21:08

duncan webster19/07/2018 18:56:47
avatar
1776 forum posts
31 photos

As they are mechanically coupled they must rotate at same speed, so I can't see any problem running them in series, provided they are the same type of motor. As someone above said, plenty of full size electric locomotives had motors in series for starting, then switched to parallel for higher speed.

Neil Wyatt19/07/2018 19:47:23
avatar
Moderator
15008 forum posts
638 photos
72 articles

If I recall correctly electric motors in parallel will tend to balance current to run at the same speed, with motors in series if one is stalled and the other is free the free one will overspeed.

duncan webster20/07/2018 08:51:50
avatar
1776 forum posts
31 photos
Posted by Neil Wyatt on 19/07/2018 19:47:23:

If I recall correctly electric motors in parallel will tend to balance current to run at the same speed, with motors in series if one is stalled and the other is free the free one will overspeed.

OP says they are coupled together mechanically, so they have to rotate at same speed

Edited By duncan webster on 20/07/2018 08:52:17

Ron Laden20/07/2018 09:34:07
685 forum posts
99 photos

Though connected mechanicalIy, I still think if wired in series and depending on how one motor fails it could create problems for the good motor. In parallel the failure of one motor shouldnt compromise the good one unless of course the motor seized and then through the mechanical connection all would stop.

Of course there is no reason to assume that the motors will fail, they probably wont but its just an "if"

Just my thoughts.

Ian S C20/07/2018 10:13:25
avatar
7115 forum posts
227 photos

Just make sure you use deep cycle batteries rather that auto starter batteries, the latter won't last, were as the former ones are the type used in DC battery banks, and mobility scooters.

Ian S C

Tim Stevens21/07/2018 20:49:47
avatar
943 forum posts

You could, though, use each motor to drive one rear wheel, and vary the current sent to each. With equal current, you would get the same speed from each motor, but if the current is not the same both sides, the vehicle will turn (or at least pull) to the lower voltage side. This, carefully arranged, will act as power steering, and if your front axle is allowed plenty of freedom (further than the usual 45 degrees both ways) you will be able to turn the vehicle in its own length. This can be both useful and impressive. The bias in power delivery might be operated by turning the steering, making the system automatic.

Cheers, Tim

Gordon W22/07/2018 11:03:41
2005 forum posts

Thanks for the ideas. This contraption will be a sort of "tug", used around the house, shifting the wheely bin etc. ( a 1 mile round trip ) Later if all is well to be a push bike pusher for road use. I think I will start with the two motors in parallel at 24V. Drive via. freewheel bearings or ratchet. At least I will some idea and at low cost.

Ron Laden22/07/2018 14:13:15
685 forum posts
99 photos

A "wheelie bin tug" well that is different Gordon.

I assume it will be ride on..? I know you intend to mechanically connect the motors will it be 2WD or 4WD..?

Please keep us posted with progress it will be interesting.


Regards

Ron

 

Edited By Ron Laden on 22/07/2018 14:15:32

Gordon W22/07/2018 15:33:34
2005 forum posts

2 wheel drive, ride-on if all goes well. Anybody remember the Good Life TV comedy ? They had a motor tiller towing a trailer, same sort of idea. Will keep posted on progress but something else has turned up today, doesn't it always?

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
méridienne Nov 18
Eccentric July 5 2018
Ausee.com.au
Shapiro
Eccentric Engineering
Warco
Sarik
emcomachinetools
Allendale Electronics
TRANSWAVE Converters
ChesterUK
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest