Any tips or experience
|The Novice Engineer||11/07/2018 23:11:34|
|22 forum posts|
I am looking for any tips or experience of turning down the ends of a hardened (60c) shaft on a Myford 7.
The shaft is for a 3D printer and I want to turn the ends down from 12mm to 8mm for a distance of 25mm on each end.
I have been trying a few cuts with mixed resullts using a CCMT insert tool.
The core of the rod is soft (ish) and the surface has been hardened and polished.
|Nick Hulme||11/07/2018 23:23:55|
|549 forum posts|
Have you checked the insert manufacturer's recommended speeds & feeds?
2873 forum posts
If the core is soft(ish) as you say, you may be able to grind the hard skin off the ends, then get in with a deep cut underneath the hard outer layer on the OD and remove it in one fell swoop. Or you might even very carefully grind the outer layer off the OD on the bench grinder then finish the softer inner material in the lathe.
Otherwise, you might have to experiment with rpm. Sometimes going slower helps with harder materials, other times with insert tooling, if you spin the job fast enough and get the metal basically up toward melting temp at the cutting point it will work too. Might sacrifice a tip or two in the process though. In this scenario, sparks and red hot swarf coming off the job are good. On such a small diameter though, the ML7 probably won't spin fast enough for this.
Edited By Hopper on 12/07/2018 00:23:05
Edited By Hopper on 12/07/2018 00:23:51
|Mark Rand||12/07/2018 00:42:16|
|476 forum posts|
For 60hRC, the happiest solution would be to find a CBN insert and use that at the fastest speed the lathe can cope with (whether the original 650-odd rpm or a faster VFD driven speed). Take shallow cuts, 1 to 8 thou with a 5-10 thou feed. If the swarf is coming off as a red cascade, then you've got it sorted.
Once you're through the case, the normal inserts will do.
Even with just carbide inserts, use the fastest speed you can get on an ML7 at that diameter
|XD 351||12/07/2018 04:55:28|
982 forum posts
The last time i had to do that i cheated ! Chucked it up in the lathe and used an angle grinder with a new wheel to knock most of the hardened skin off then machined it with my normal carbide tooling . One reason for this is i found the tool tended to push off a lot rather than cut as the skin was thicker than i expected - close to a mm from memory .
You could try taking a deeper cut and try to get under the hardening .
|Niels Abildgaard||12/07/2018 05:26:01|
|123 forum posts|
ccMt means moulded .ccGt means ground and that is what counts for hard things
Edited By Niels Abildgaard on 12/07/2018 05:27:15
|Andrew Johnston||12/07/2018 08:02:13|
4037 forum posts
It's perfectly possible to turn hardened steel with ordinary CCMT style inserts, but for best results I'd agree with Mark and go for CBN inserts. Just sit down before looking at prices.
The posts in this thread on turning hardened silver steel may be of interest:
|john carruthers||12/07/2018 08:20:30|
561 forum posts
60c shaft, was it induction hardened? could it be annealed?
|not done it yet||12/07/2018 10:11:51|
|2042 forum posts|
If turning the shaft is too difficult, an alternative might be to bore the shaft and insert smaller, softer ends?
Edited By not done it yet on 12/07/2018 10:12:38
|Michael Gilligan||12/07/2018 10:16:34|
11609 forum posts
|Mark Rand||12/07/2018 22:35:19|
|476 forum posts||
They can be surprisingly reasonable if you don't buy from a 'name brand' supplier. Here's one I just spotted.
I got mine from a second hand tool dealer (findurstuff on EBay. No connection etc) and the CCMT 09XX tool holder I needed for them cost more than the five inserts.
|Neil Lickfold||12/07/2018 22:57:44|
|459 forum posts|
I have found that the ccgt 09 and ccgt 06 inserts from kyocera on the myford are best. You want around 400 rpm for the hard skin and then around 600 for the rest. Get the small radius 0.2mm inserts and take no more than 0.2mm cuts (0.4mm diameter ) at about 0.05mm per rev,(2 thou per rev) feedrate. If it gets hot, use water or some coolant on it. I have a picture of the ccgt inserts that I turn bearing races with in my album.
In my experience , unless you can get a 0.2mm cbn and they are expensive, the regular coated carbide will be a far better choice on a Myford lathe.
|188 forum posts|
For the odd job you can search for CBN inserts off ebay, youl'll find branded inserts which although used are still good. That said to run CBN effectively very high speeds are required and is mostly used on cnc machines.
I have recently purchased these : **LINK**
3268 forum posts
Slow speed, high torque with carbide or cobalt tooling
Finish at high speed with light cuts
Shapers munch through everything and their secret is slow speed with masses of torque
Edited By Ady1 on 13/07/2018 00:28:57
|Martin Connelly||13/07/2018 11:07:04|
693 forum posts
I have turned hardened ball screws but not on a Myford. I used carbide inserts, not a massive speed but certainly an aggressive feed rate. This got rid of the hardened outer layer and allowed a more typical turning process when the hard skin was gone. This was also with an interrupted cut due to the outer layer being a spiral groove. The stock was held in a collet.
I think I used absolute minimum overhang for the tool holder and ball screw to keep everything as stiff as possible. I may also have done a few millimetres at a time and pushed the stock out a bit more after each section of a few millimetres was done. I'm sorry I can't be more exact, it was a few years ago.
|852 forum posts|
The only way i could turn ultra hard Perkins valves down on an ML7 was to use Kenametal NR 48R K68 inserts running in excess of 1000rpm 1phase 1hp motor.
|John Reese||14/07/2018 03:57:22|
|542 forum posts|
You should have no problem using carbide inserts. I have cut lots of induction hardened and chromed piston rod material on my South Bend 10K. It is just a 9" lathe raised 1/2". I use a relatively high speed and light cut until I get through the hard layer. Expect the chips to come off red. The carbide I use for that is of unknown grade. It is just carbide I don't mind destroying.
|The Novice Engineer||17/07/2018 22:41:09|
|22 forum posts|
Just a quick update.
I sucessfully completed the job using CCGT 09 carbide tool running at 300 RPM with a 30' (0.75mm) depth of cut working dry. The swarf came off cleanly and a dark blue colour. The surface was rough but I was then able to use another CCGT tool at 1800 RPM to clean up the shaft to finish size.
Thanks for all your responses, gave me confidence to get stuck in !
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.