|Stephen Follows||23/01/2018 23:22:38|
50 forum posts
I have a Rothernberger MAPP gas torch that was described as being good for brazing and silver soldering. I find that it does not give enough heat for either. Any suggestions as to what to use? Don't really want to go to the expense of oxy acetylene as I don't do a lot of this kind of work.
1585 forum posts
For small items it should be fine, I used to use mine alot. What are you trying to solder?
|1276 forum posts|
Someone else asked a very similar question here earlier tonight...
15773 forum posts
The good for silver soldering applies to small bore tubing used for refridgeration and H&V as Rotheernberger stuff is aimed at that market eg plumbers.
When choosing a torch look at the Kw rating and not the temperature, you want around 7Kw as a general burner with the ability to fit larger and smaller burners
|David George 1||24/01/2018 07:44:52|
841 forum posts
I have a bullfinch torch works well for me
|Nick Hulme||24/01/2018 08:45:30|
|694 forum posts|
Are you using adequate refractory material under and around the work to radiate heat back at it from all sides?
A proper brazing hearth is worth several Kilowatts of torch power,
842 forum posts
Plus 1 for Bulfinch I have used mine for over 40 years now, I have several nozzles but use in the main the largest and the next down, have to check the exact numbers if anyone interested!
There is some very useful and easy to digest safety & technical info on the Bulfinch site **LINK** plus as far as I know they are made in Britain so worth supporting our industry!
138 forum posts
OK, so clickbait worked...
But what I discovered looking at the site was 'Safeflame' - generating hydrogen and oxygen supplies by electrical separation of water to fuel the burner. What a great idea.
But does it exist? Is it available in 'hobby' style price ranges? Could not find any products....
|CuP Alloys 1||24/01/2018 11:06:02|
192 forum posts
|Sievert every time! They offer the widest range of burners to suit all applications and are available with the best technical back up relating to silver soldering. If there are problems the answer ALWAYS lies behind the torch! Seek sound advice.|
01909 547248 is a good place to start!
|254 forum posts|
I tried a Rothenberger Mapp gas torch before I bit the bullet and got a set of bottles from SGS Gases. The only way I could get it to do anything bigger than say 3/32" thick was to use a BIG old parrafin blowlamp to increase the heat input. Still got the Rothenberger but its only used for quick heat up and plumbing jobs.
Edited By Oldiron on 24/01/2018 11:10:29
|Bob Youldon||24/01/2018 11:29:40|
|183 forum posts|
Good morning Stephen,
I have to agree with CuP, the Sievert range will do most jobs, As a satisfied user from the mid sixties and having silver brazed up to and including large 5" gauge locomotive copper boilers down to fine scale steel fabrications i would not consider any other brand. I know of the Bullfinch torches but I'm unable to give an opinion and know of the Rothenberger brand, those being generally designed for specific purposes mainly associated with the plumbing, heating and air conditioning trades.
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.