|Jonathan Mead||16/11/2016 10:15:06|
30 forum posts
I'm thinking of getting a slightly larger lathe and the Warco 240B has caught my eye - simple machine without all of the potential problems that come with electronic speed control systems and capable of a good speed range from 125RPM upwards. Does anyone on the forum have one, and if so, what are their experiences?
|Chris Evans 6||16/11/2016 10:21:02|
|1335 forum posts|
I have never seen one but 125 RPM is a bit quick if you want to cut course threads to a shoulder.
|Rik Shaw||16/11/2016 11:00:39|
1206 forum posts
Chris - If he is as windy as I am he'd use something like this anyway:
4329 forum posts
Definitely looks like a better option long term than an electronic speed control. But no back gear. A little bit of ingenuity should be able to add that and recover some of the cost with an article in MEW.
I just can't understand why Warco and a few others put so little real information on the website - like what are the actual speeds between 125 and 2000 and about a dozen photographs too.
It is about the size of a Boxford which would be cheaper but not new.
|John Rudd||16/11/2016 15:13:47|
|1328 forum posts|
Looks like a 918 revival.....very similar specification if not the same....
|Nigel (egi)||11/09/2018 21:15:58|
22 forum posts
I've had a Warco WM240B for some years and I love it
I keep thinking about upgrading it with a variable speed motor as the combinational of belt drive and variable speed would give me a huge range of speeds, but just too busy making models and the few speeds I have I find work very well.
|Mick B1||12/09/2018 16:53:30|
|868 forum posts|
I went for the WM250V for the powered crossfeed and crossslide t-slots, which enable lots of versatile light milling in a vertical slide.
I've had no trouble whatever with the speed control in about 3 1/2 years of almost daily use.
|Dave Smith 14||12/09/2018 19:20:59|
|55 forum posts|
Second the 250V. Mine is now 6 years old, I have had it three years, no problems with the speed control. The powered cross feed I would not want to live without.
2224 forum posts
Concur with the WM250V, the powered X feed is very, very, useful especially when parting off under power. Had mine since 2012 & it has served me well so far.
|Jim Nic||14/09/2018 10:18:49|
165 forum posts
I've had a 240 since 2011 and find it a good lathe for my model building needs. Mine is the variable speed model which I like because of the ability to alter the speed on the fly if I'm not getting the results I want. I'll also tempt fate and say the variable speed has been no trouble.
I sometimes wish I had spent a little more and bought the 250 as others are suggesting here but to do that now is more than a little more, it's the difference between £1000 and £1700!
|Ian Thomson 2||19/11/2018 18:05:24|
|14 forum posts|
I have just had to replace the control board on my wood turning lathe. I am thinking now that I should avoid the lathes with DC motors and variable speed.
This does not leave many options - the 240B is probably the cheapest of them.
Is there a 3 phase motor same size, spindle and comparable power that can drop in and be driven by a VFD?
|52 forum posts|
I have the variable speed 240 with dc motor. I found that it lacks torque at low speed, just when it is needed. I made a speed reduction system for it that vastly improved the situation. Yes, written up as an article for MEW but has been in Neil's in-tray for a long time.
|John Rudd||20/11/2018 19:10:39|
|1328 forum posts|
If you can measure the existing motor's spindle, body diameter/length and give some idea the amount of space at the back of the motor, that would help...what horsepower is the motor? Or wattage..the new model has a brushless 1.1kw motor...
Edited By John Rudd on 20/11/2018 19:12:28
|Ian Thomson 2||20/11/2018 22:22:39|
|14 forum posts|
I was thinking of the 240D with no speed control - a 550W motor in that one.
I don't have one yet.Still considering Warco 240D / Warco 250V (Too much money now) / SC4 / Boxford AUD/BUD.
Last week I was almost decided on the SC4, but now the speed controller has gone on my wood turning lathe, I am reconsidering.
It looks like the 240D is a reasonable specification at a good price. No DC control board to go wrong.
In the future it could be upgraded for a reasonable low cost to the more reliable 3 phase AC motor and VFD the changing speed by adjusting belts gets too much of a chore. I would like to know that a drop in replacement 3 phase motor is available (same size, same mounting, same spindle, similar power etc.).
If anyone has a WM240D and can see any identification marks on the motor, this would be useful.
|933 forum posts|
Very likely a 3ph motor of larger capacity say 2hp will have a larger case and spindle size. Definately wouldnt want to drop below a 1 1/2hp motor which will still be bigger than the 1ph.
When thats done you still have no brake even if its supposedly built in the the invertor, scary. Cant beat a spindle start for that with foot brake.
2011 about £1k, bet they still want that used bare in mind only cost £750 delivered for a proper English M300, chalk and cheese!
|Ian Thomson 2||20/11/2018 22:46:28|
|14 forum posts|
M300 for £750 delivered! Where? Browsing Ebay quickly, they are £3K+.
Too big for me anyway. I could just squeeze in a short bed AUD/BUD if I could find a good metric one.
Edited By Ian Thomson 2 on 20/11/2018 22:47:20
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.