|Sam Longley 1||19/01/2016 18:10:56|
|732 forum posts|
So what do forumites think of model engineers workshop as a magazine?
Years ago I used to have RC&ME which had lots of engineering articles. Now, however, it is aeroplanes & helicopters. Whilst I am a member of a model aero club I find the mag disapointing as it does not give much " how to" info
So having seen the note that there was an article about the Drummond ( i have an "M" I shot off to W H Smiths. Disaster, - not on the shelves. If the mag has lots of info on machining I will invest in a subscription, but if it is all about steam trains chuffing up some valley or other than it will be of no interest
However without getting my hands on a copy i just wondered if model engineers actually think that it is an informative mag, or like a lot of magazines - all about someone's latest holiday
Finally - why has that little smiley plonked itself in the script? have I a little lodger?
Edited By Sam Longley 1 on 19/01/2016 18:11:33
Edited By Sam Longley 1 on 19/01/2016 18:12:37
Edited By JasonB on 19/01/2016 18:17:40
17035 forum posts
I have moved Sam's post here rather than have it tagged onto an old one.
If you follow " with ) you get
Sam there is an example of MEW here
MEW has very little on models or days out etc, thats reserved for ME
Edited By JasonB on 19/01/2016 18:29:24
|3631 forum posts|
Useful that Jason.
|Boiler Bri||19/01/2016 20:05:48|
813 forum posts
Hi Sam, why not look at the workshop series of books, these are ideal if you are looking for basic advice and step by step help. I have been an engineer for a long time and certainly do not know it all. If I am stuck I have a browse through them and I usually find what I'm looking for.
|Steve Withnell||19/01/2016 20:52:39|
796 forum posts
I tend to search youtube! Some really nice work comes up.
Edited By Steve Withnell on 19/01/2016 20:54:24
|Neil Wyatt||19/01/2016 20:54:05|
17052 forum posts
I think it's a bl**dy brilliant magazine.
But seriously, look here www.model-engineer.co.uk/editorial/page.asp?p=250 for a preview of the latest issue.
Edited By Neil Wyatt on 19/01/2016 20:57:20
|Paul Lousick||19/01/2016 21:01:06|
|1282 forum posts|
I would recommend MEW to anyone interested in model engineering. Lots of interesting projects and practical advise from members. I would also suggest that you subscribe to the digital archive so you can access older publications which contain many beginner articles.
|Sam Longley 1||19/01/2016 21:34:44|
|732 forum posts|
That would be a good idea. All I need to do now is follow the links & find out how to subscribe.
by the way- Apologies to the mods for putting in wrong place.
Being new here means i do not know my way around yet & there are many different blocks of thread. The notification email is not as good as some & i do tend to forget where i have posted. Too many blocks is my first thought. Buy Hey! I am new here
|Sam Longley 1||19/01/2016 21:35:55|
|732 forum posts|
Birthday in Feb & 4 titles have already been selected. Just see what transpires
|Danny M2Z||20/01/2016 03:23:37|
783 forum posts
Brilliant, always something to learn.
I even started to read about topics that do not particularly interest me because hidden away in the articles are some gems about a technique which could be useful for other projects.
The only problem here in Australia seems to be the local subscriber's distribution tales of woe so I obtain my (reserved) copies from my friendly local newsagent and so help to keep them in business (small town).
Also the correct title is Model Engineers' Workshop to be a bit pedantic lol.
* Danny M *
Edited By Danny M2Z on 20/01/2016 03:24:09
|David Clark 1||20/01/2016 09:37:35|
3357 forum posts
Neil, when you preview the next issue as mentioned above can you include on sale date in the preview?
|Michael Gilligan||20/01/2016 10:06:35|
14760 forum posts
Noting that the all-important and oft-discussed apostrophe is missing from the text in the 'current-issue' link in the menu frame on the forum pages .... SHOCK, HORROR
Now; as for the contents ... Quite well balanced, and very good value
|XD 351||20/01/2016 10:10:08|
1392 forum posts
It tops my list of all the magazines i read !
Although Model Engineer and Australian Model Engineers magazines are nipping at its heels as far as i'm concerned .
I also subscribe to home shop machinist and machinist workshop and Model Engine builder but a few things i see that differ significantly from the UK and Australian magazines are :
The U.S based magazines are smaller and seem to have much more advertizing and the seem to have gunsmithing tagged to the magazine , while i personaly don't mind that 3 or 4 pages of modifying an AR15 Assault rifle is of little use to me as they are banned here in Australia .
I think i will trim my subscription list this year back to MEW ,ME & AME .
If you modify machines or build your own tooling MEW is for you , If you're into Making models then ME is what you want and if you live in Australia you should buy AME anad support the local rag .
692 forum posts
I think that MEW is a super magazine. I have recently changed my subscription from ME to MEW. ME is also very good for long series on particular models but I prefer workshop projects. I agree that the digital subscription option is very good giving access to the archived editions which contain a wealth of information.
Neil, keep up the good work as editor and many thanks for always producing an interesting and informative magazine.
|Tim Stevens||20/01/2016 10:20:30|
1123 forum posts
The only thing I find frustrating is the splitting of articles. This means that I get keen to learn how certain problems were addressed, only to find that by the time the series ends (several months later) I have completely lost track of the early stuff (or gone on to something else).
It does put an extreme load on failing memories when articles start in the middle with no paragraph saying 'The story so far ...'
It also can cause problems if you want to separate the sections of a story page by page to keep them together, only to find that you have removed pages with other stuff on the back ...
I wonder how many other readers are well down the slippery slope of failing memory?
|Russell Eberhardt||20/01/2016 10:51:50|
2527 forum posts
I would answer that if only I could remember
Now, what was I doing?
|3142 forum posts|
If I want to keep pages of an article together for whatever reason, I simply scan them and print if needed. That way they can descend into the workshop and it does not matter if they get a little oily.
|3631 forum posts|
I haven't taken either magazine for a long time now but I suspect that ME will still give more details on actually making things. That makes the articles rather long. MEW was generally more short and quick with varying amount of detail.
I was trained as a toolmaker. That's ok and useful but working at home is a little different. The toolrooms I have been in have every conceivable piece of equipment. There is no need to make do with what's about.
Where I would be inclined to point people is towards certain books. The workshop practice series for instance. Some are a bit indifferent but many for the cost are pretty good. A good book on "making do" that covers a number of things is one of the Projects for a Unimat books. It includes plans for a small traction engine.
ME as I see it is largely concerned with making everything on a Myford lathe along with a vertical slide and one or two other bits and pieces. Maybe milling machines are expected now. No idea as it's a very long time since I bought one. If everything is going to be made on a lathe the difficult aspect is just how to set the work up. There are plenty of ideas concerning that aspect in ME articles especially for making tooling. Some have been reprinted into books. From what I have seen these can be a bit mixed.
I haven't much interest in chuff chuffs on rails either so can appreciate the OP's feelings. Actually I did know some one that made some of the difficult bits for people making these. He made jigs and took no notice of what was in the articles as he knew it would cause problems. He was a toolmaker. Covering making a loco in fine detail would take rather a lot of editions.
People like Neil have a tough life when asked to keep everybody happy. At one level people just want plans and at another lots and lots of detail.
Google can be useful eg making model ic engines bought up this page
Youtube can be too but there are some people about that have some strange ideas. It pays to take info from a number of sources and spend some time thinking about it. I suspect a lot of the problems people have comes down to confidence really and wanting to be told exactly what to do. There are lots of ways of cracking an egg. Some are better than others.
4889 forum posts
"I haven't much interest in chuff chuffs on rails either so can appreciate the OP's feelings."
That's a bit like saying I don't drink beer so will never go into a pub. The locomotives are only a part of the content and even those articles have useful machining information.
17035 forum posts
John W suggest you have a look through a few recent MEs, not only will you find milling machines in use but it has even moved on to CNC. Can't remember when I last saw a vertical slide in the pages
I too have little interest in Locos but find enough in there to make it worth keeping up my subscription. Chuff Chuffs are only one aspect of model engineering
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.