Here is a list of all the postings Ian P has made in our forums. Click on a thread name to jump to the thread.
|Thread: Coronavirus death stats|
I fully respect your decision and I would not try and persuade you to change it and certainly would not have a go at you. My only question is, what facts or information do you base your decision on?
|Thread: Collet chuck for workholding on the mill|
Fully follow and understand what you are saying, I use the same technique often, however its determining the point of 'just touches' that introduces uncertainty of position, whereas clamping only in a downwards direction (whether vise or a block) minimises any error.
There have been several methods mentioned in this thread so its not clear which one you are referring to, however when I put anything in a vice I just tighten it too
If the workpiece is already held on a pin in the mill spindle then its only safe to close the vice jaws if the vice is free to move, which is what the OP showed originally.
I think there is a big difference between large and small workpieces when using a self-alignnent technique.
Centralising (say) a 3mm diameter pin in a collet block already gripped in an unclamped heavy/bulky vice is not what I would call a sound method. I too dont use a key to locate the vice but once I clock it into position avoid moving it unless its absolutely essential. Since the DRO knows where the vice reference faces are it knows the position of the collet block axis (on the square block anyway, only one axis on the hex block).
Its debatable whether setting by DRO will be any better or worse than locating mechanically but I JH's method looks optimum for small components, just a pity that standard collet blocks dont have a deep groove at the 'bottom' end into which toe clamps could sit.
I too use a block in the vice (although not everyone has them) but I can see a big advantage with the JH method.
Accurately centering a block gripped in the vise can take time whereas allowing the job to self-centralise before tightening the clamps is near instant.
|Thread: Boring a circular groove|
Depends on what you mean by 'above'.
Chris supplied a drawing that was nearly as undecipherable as his question.
So if this is a half round groove running the whole width of the face, it odd that you asked about doing it by boring? Even odder that you had to ask at all .
From your previous posts and work that you have shown or discussed its obvious that you are fairly well skilled and knowledgeable, my initial thought was that this groove was somehow in a difficult area to access.
I would like to respectfully ask that in future you take a little time composing your questions.
I wonder why I have that 'here we go again' feeling....
Many times previously, threads have developed a life of there own with many members suggesting solutions for problems the OP never even thought existed. Without knowing what Chris wants all we can go on is guesswork. I know I mentioned O-ring but TBH it was a bit tongue in cheek (O-rings are rarely or never fitted to semicircular grooves).
To me a groove is a groove. A stationary D-bit would work as a form tool but its an unlikely tool to use in the lathe or mill because most bit are relatively long so holding it would not be easy.
That would create a circular (semicircular in section) depression, its not a shape I would describe as a groove as one would expect a groove to have a length dimension.
I think you will need to explain more clearly what you are trying to do.
'Bottom of cube' could be anything.
|Thread: Advice please - Brushless motors|
It certainly looks good for the money!
Hard to tell from the pictures what the motor is, I have seen hundreds of different brushless motors over the years but no examples of ones used in cordless power tools.
The listing first picture shows something that might be the motor (with what looks like a section picture of heavy duty cable! ) but its hard to reconcile that with the the other computer generated images that appear to show a fairly small diameter motor. Ballraces appear in one picture but maybe they are just for decoration. Does the charger come with a UK mains plug or if not is that the reason for the strategically placed bit of white cloth.
I'm still tempted to get one though!
Edit, White cloth is gloves!
Edited By Ian P on 22/12/2020 22:35:12
When there is a motor controlled by electronics there is little difference on cost whether the speed is set by a potentiometer or a multiposition switch.
'Ring of magnets around a set of coils' hints of it being an external rotor motor (often with silly description of being an 'Outrunner' similar to the type used in model aircraft. Motor speed is controlled by changing the commutation frequency.
What make and model is it, also the one Ady mentioned withe the very high tourque?
|Thread: Drilling then Tapping in Drill Press|
As others have said ditch the spring loaded widget and use the chuck.
I am fortunate in having a VFD on my Fobco. I set it up so the lowest frequency is 4Hz at which speed it has little torque but I use it for tapping (with the tap in the chuck) from M2 upwards. (I have fingertip reverse switch) I frequently tap scores of 1/4" and 3/8" UNC in 10mm ali plates not clamped down so it aligns itself to the tap.
|Thread: Slot drill hole size?|
Hole with flat bottom, why not just use a flat bottom drill?
Seems to be a standard engineering cutting tool, one suggested use is starting a hole on a curved surface (not with a pistol drill I hope!).
Link below is to a carbide one but presumably HSS are made
|Thread: Lathe improvements?|
What a strange outlook!
Despite the title this is not just a forum for model engineers, who I am sure do not all waste time and money.
There are many avid user of this forum that have no interest on models or steam.
That certainly looks a substantial spindle assembly. Presume you have access to a large lathe and other engineering facilities to braze and machine a spindle of that size. (machined after brazing?)
I agree about the vulnerability of screwed on chucks but having gone to the trouble you have, why not elect for camlock mount?
|Thread: Beginner milling chuck key question|
I've never crossdrilled chuck keys but usually fitted a grubscrew axially into the main bar which already has a centre holes from turning operations. A dimple in the cross bar and jobs a good-un
|Thread: Machining Ball Screws Accurately|
Its the last sentence that is the problem, See Joe's post about clocking
|Thread: Whitworth v UNC|
3/8"x16 is a thread size that has become standard in the film and video industry (as has 1/4x20).
I know there is an ISO standard for the 1/4" thread (probably one too for the 3/8" so all camera and grip equipment have male and female threads that work with legacy UNC and Whitworth kit.
Must add though that these fixings are mostly hand tightened and not under great stress.
Edited by punching that smiley up its bracket
Edited By Ian P on 17/11/2020 20:50:12
|Thread: Machining flats on bar stock|
I did a similar thing on a 20mm diameter bar 1.8m long. I used a precision level (clamped to the first machined flat) as a reference. I have (temporarily) forgotten how I allowed for the milling machine not being precisely level but as its not bolted down I made sure it did not move between operations.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.